Monsters And Men Review

Monsters and Men
In north Manhattan, three men find their lives changed after white police kill an unarmed African-American man on the street. As they become embroiled in the situation, their livelihoods are drastically threatened.

by Alex Godfrey |
Published on
Release Date:

16 Jan 2019

Original Title:

Monsters And Men

Monsters And Men feels almost supernaturally contemporary, not because of the issues it explores — racist profiling, unjust killings caught on camera and social media-fuelled street protests — but because it dives into the conversation around such events. Today’s generation feels particularly politically charged, activism pronounced and pervasive, and Monsters And Men isn’t interested in the immediate implications of events as much as it is the way in which those looking on, from up-close or afar, factor such events into their own lives, navigating how they eat away at their psyches.

To present different angles, debut feature writer-director Reinaldo Marcus Green goes episodic, following three people as they size up the death of an unarmed black man (no doubt inspired by Eric Garner) at the hands of white NYPD cops. Green delves deep into the grey areas. The protagonists — an enraged bystander (Anthony Ramos) who films the killing, a cop (John David Washington) with a confused conscience, and a young man inspired to take a stand (Kelvin Harrison Jr) — all wrestle with the potential consequences of getting involved, their conflicts of interest challenged. It’s provocative stuff, prodding at us to ask ourselves how much we are willing to sacrifice in order to honour our moral compasses.

Stylish, considered filmmaking.

It’s a meditative exploration, with Pat Scola’s soft, warm cinematography enhancing Green’s compassion, and soulful, haunted performances across the board. Philosophically, it is cohesive. Narratively, it doesn’t hit so hard: there are hints that the strands might intertwine, but they barely do, and with the characters so well drawn, it feels like a loss when they each disappear, making way for the next just as their stories gather steam.

This anthology feel softens the blow, but Green is more interested in questions than answers. Monsters And Men tackles its issues thoughtfully, not going for tidy resolutions, and in that respect it feels appropriate. It is stylish, considered filmmaking.

Both cinematic and literary, this is mature, textured work. Gently prodding at you rather than grabbing you by the throat, it is intentionally unexplosive, but lights a fire nevertheless.
Just so you know, whilst we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website, we never allow this to influence product selections - read why you should trust us