Register  |   Log In  |  
Sign up to our weekly newsletter    
Empire Magazine and iPad
Follow Me on Pinterest YouTube Tumblr
Trending On Empire
The Future Of Film
The 100 Greatest Video Games
Robin Williams: The Big Interview
Kevin Feige:
My Movie Life

The Marvel supremo's pick of the flicks
Want To Be An Empire Journalist?
Find out how here
Movie News

Tak3n Trailer Smashes Online
It ends here, so we're promised
Dominic Cooper Boards Marvel's Agent Carter
The young Howard Stark is officially back
New Trailer For Horrible Bosses 2
How to suck at business without really trying...
Alec Baldwin And Kevin Spacey Set For Boss Baby
From DreamWorks Animation
Netflix To Simultaneously Release Crouching Tiger 2
Streaming service makes big deal
There's A Tetris Movie In The Works
We're not kidding
Big Headed For TV
Rush Hour will also become a show
David Fincher Will Direct The Full First Season Of HBO's Utopia
He'll be busy next year...
New Look At Oscar Isaac In A Most Violent Year
J. C. Chandor's Once Upon A Time In America
Teaser Trailer For Inherent Vice
Paul Thomas Anderson does Thomas Pynchon
Billy Elliot Beats The Equalizer
Live screening of stage musical tops the UK box office
More Movie News

26 September 2014
The Imitation Game Decodes A New Poster
Benedict Cumberbatch is Mr. E. Nigma
More Movie News

The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies
12 December 2014
Penguins Of Madagascar
05 December 2014
The Imitation Game
14 November 2014
More Future Films

August: Osage County (2014)
Empire Star Rating
12 Years A Slave (2014)
Empire Star Rating
The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug (2013)
Empire Star Rating
The Fifth Estate (2013)
Empire Star Rating
Star Trek Into Darkness (2013)
Empire Star Rating
More new cinemas releases
DVD & Blu-ray releases

Some Speculation On The Hobbit Finale
Benedict Cumberbatch reveals tidbit?

05 January 2012  |  Written by Helen O'Hara  |  Source: Exclusive

submit to reddit

Some Speculation On The Hobbit Finale

The following is both complete conjecture and a possible spoiler for The Hobbit: There And Back Again, so please think carefully before continuing. But when we spoke to Benedict Cumberbatch on set of Sherlock a little while back, we asked him about his roles in Peter Jackson's new epic, and he said something that may very well be a spoiler, so let's discuss that just a bit.

Cumberbatch said of his role," I’m playing Smaug through motion-capture and voicing the Necromancer, which is a character in the Five Legions War or something which I’m meant to understand. He’s not actually in the original Hobbit. It’s something [Peter Jackson]’s taken from Lord Of The Rings that he wants to put in there."

Now those familiar with the book will notice immediately the big new piece of information here. Assuming that Cumberbatch does mean the Battle of Five Armies (which seems safe), then this points to one way that Peter Jackson and co. have expanded the book's story to fill two films, and provide a more seamless link to The Lord Of The Rings.

Readers will know that the Necromancer is Sauron, and that Gandalf disappears halfway through (the book of) The Hobbit to lead a coalition force and drive the Necromancer out of his Mirkwood stronghold. But in the book they dispatch the Necromancer back to (as it turns out) Mordor well before the Battle of Five Armies. Here, however, it looks like he's going to turn up to the finale in person, presumably at the head of the goblin and Warg army, and face Gandalf's team there.

If that is the case, it's a narratively neat way to combine the two story threads, that of Bilbo and the dwarves and the other following Gandalf and his team. It also gives the goblins a stronger motivation to suddenly turn up: in the book, they're avenging the earlier death of one of their leaders and (like all the other armies present) hoping to get their grubby hands on the dragon's hoard. If they're incited or led by Sauron, however, their actions will hang more coherently with their behaviour later in Lord Of The Rings.

Of course, this is all just speculation for now. We'll know more when we see The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey this December 14, and see for sure with the release of There And Back Again in 2013.


What do you think of this theory?
Duh! Obvious.
Well, it makes sense based on the little we know...
It's not in the book. I am therefore opposed.
I am unconvinced by your argument.
Duh! Totally wrong.
  View results without voting

Have Your Say
To comment on this, and all articles, register for free or login now.

Don Cheadle Updates On Miles Davis Film
His will be the gangster version
Denzel Washington Could Be The Equalizer
Update: He's in!

Your Comments

If Sauron appears as the Necromancer (whether leading the Goblin/Warg army or just torturing Thrain in Dol Guldur in some film prelude a-la Last Alliance Battle in LOTR) would it not be too far-fetched to in addition to Galadriel and Saurman appearing in the White Council, to also see Legolas with Thranduil and the Wood elves, black riders (could the Lord of the Nazgul lead the attack in the Battle of Five Armies as "The Witch King of Angmar" as reference him with his title in the LO More

Posted by Fingolfin64 at 16:14 on 08 January 2012 | Report This Post

If Sauron appears as the Necromancer (whether leading the Goblin/Warg army or just torturing Thrain in Dol Guldur in some film prelude a-la Last Alliance Battle in LOTR) would it not be too far-fetched to in addition to Galadriel and Saruman appearing in the White Council, to also see Legolas with Thranduil and the Wood elves, the black riders (could the Lord of the Nazgul lead the attack in the Battle of Five Armies as "The Witch King of Angmar" as Gandalf references him in ROTK movie), Gimli More

Posted by Fingolfin64 at 16:14 on 08 January 2012 | Report This Post

RE: Thought
I can see it happening, it would make more sense to finally get Sauron physical. More

Posted by Spaldron at 12:26 on 06 January 2012 | Report This Post

RE: Thought
I think its obvious Benedict isn't a Tolkien fan, unless he's being a piss taker, which isn't a real problem. Neither was Viggo apparently, but his son was. Possible Spoilers ahead: Anyhow, if you read some of the Tolkein lore then the whole 'Necromancer' could be interesting. Put simply, its Sauron as a weaker form. He takes over this tower named Dol Guldur (i think, could be wrong) and kidnaps Thorin's (leader of the Dwarves in 'The Hobbit') Dad. He is rescued later by Gandalf, and More

Posted by BrooksyTHX1138 at 11:26 on 06 January 2012 | Report This Post

RE: Thought
A few thoughts:   - Given the total vagueness of the quote, it's possible that Cumberbatch isn't a big Tolkien fan and hasn't a clue how significant a poor or mistaken choice of words can be for the rabid fanbase. Or... - For secrecy reasons, Cumberbatch has only received the portions of the script where he has to voice dialogue, and therefore isn't 100% sure as to the extent of the Necromancer's part in the film(s). (This conjecture may be strengthened if Cumberbatch isn't au fait w More

Posted by BelfastBoy at 10:33 on 06 January 2012 | Report This Post

Cumberbatch might have been talking about the attack on dol guldur and just mispoke! More

Posted by hauntbert at 06:10 on 06 January 2012 | Report This Post

If this rings true, Sir PJ has lost me as a first-night customer; I will wait and learn if this 'spoiler' takes place in some form. If the Necromancer is written in where Tolkien explicitly wrote him out? For me this is too much to bear. Unfinished Tales was unfinished but the Hobbit was a complete and coherent work. I found it quite entertaining to read alternative story lines but do not want to see them locked in cellulose. More

Posted by jim.pdxus at 04:46 on 06 January 2012 | Report This Post

Titbit ....
Not 'tidbit'. More

Posted by Jon 79 at 01:02 on 06 January 2012 | Report This Post

Possible spoiler based on the original material to cover your eyes if you don't want to know... ...seeing as Tolkien revised the events of The Hobbit as seen in The Unfinished Tales resulting in Galdalf setting things in motion with the dwarfs because he knew Sauron wanted to use Smaug as a weapon and was determined to prevent this from happening. Makes sense then as to why The Necromancer would turn up at the battle. More

Posted by BRob at 23:01 on 05 January 2012 | Report This Post

Not exactly sure if I like this. We'll see. More

Posted by Carne at 22:26 on 05 January 2012 | Report This Post

You turned out in your hundreds and thousands, and here are the results... Browse the full list

The Future Of Film: Lasers Will Save 3D (If Your Cinema Is Big Enough)
Big will be beautiful in the brave new world of frickin' laser beam projection

The Bond Girls Who Made It Big
The actresses who overcame the curse of 007 to forge successful careers

The Future Of Film: A Woman Will Direct Star Wars
No longer a men’s club, Hollywood is going to start opening its doors...

The Empire Podcast #130: Interviews With Rosamund Pike, Lee Child And Antoine Fuqua
The Gone Girl star, Jack Reacher author and The Equalizer director pop in for a chat

The Future Of Film: Movie Posters Will Talk To You (And Buy Your Tickets)
Movie posters will be bigger, better... and talk to you?

The 50 Greatest Voice Performances In Movies
Who has the most talented tonsils in town?

25 Movie Songs Bigger Than The Movie
The film tunes that transcend their origins...

Subscribe to Empire magazine
Get 6 Issues Of Empire For Only £15!

Get exclusive subscriber-only covers each month!

Subscribe today

Subscribe to Empire iPad edition
Get The Empire iPad Edition Today

Subscribe and save maney on annual digital subscription

Subscribe today
Buy single issues

Get 6 issues of Empire for just £15!
Get the world's greatest movie magazine delivered straight to your door! Subscribe today!
Empire's Film Studies 101 Series
Everything you ever wanted to know about filmmaking but were afraid to ask...
The Empire iPad Edition
With exclusive extras, interactive features, trailers and much more! Download now
Home  |  News  |  Blogs  |  Reviews  |  Future Films  |  Features  |  Interviews  |  Images  |  Competitions  |  Forum  |  iPad  |  Podcast  |  Magazine Contact Us  |  Empire FAQ  |  Subscribe To Empire  |  Register
© Bauer Consumer Media Ltd  |  Legal Info  |  Editorial Complaints  |  Privacy Policy  |  Bauer Entertainment Network
Bauer Consumer Media Ltd (company number 01176085 and registered address 1 Lincoln Court, Lincoln Road, Peterborough, England PE1 2RF)