| Maybe Im a little confused... |
Although I firmly believe that Del Toro is one of the most talented directors to enter the circuit in a long while, I am strangely proud of his move away from the project (based on the reasons that Jackson stated). I do love Tolkien's epic masterpiece, but it seems a little overkill to split up the prequel into different parts. I mean, there is only one book; would it have been that difficult to squeeze it into one film? And six years??? Again, this is the prequel. It was a great story, of c More
Posted by chewynewyork at 18:58 on 07 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| depressing |
How comes Hollywood can churn out rubbish after rubbish, remake after remake - filmsthat no one wants to see, yet here we have a story everyone wants to see committed to film, two film makers who really want to make it, and a guarantee of a major box office hit - that somehow can't find its way out of development hell.? More
Posted by jkemal at 15:54 on 07 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
we're sure it was a "hard hobbit to break"...
brilliant stuff Chris, just brilliant!!! More
Posted by skyrodent at 12:16 on 07 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Thank the lord (of the rings)! |
Why is everyone so upset? Although Pan's Labyrinth is ace both Hellboys were massively overrated disappointments. C'mon Jackson - get off your slimmed down arse and direct the movies yourself. More
Posted by AndyKirk at 11:57 on 05 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Talk about feeling deflated! |
Well, when I originally heard that the Hobbit was going to be made I was pretty excited. What could be better than returning to the fantastical world of Middle Earth?. Then I hear Mr Del Toro was up for the position in the directors chair.....Wicked! He is definitely one of my favourite directors, with a truly original and dark style. Who the hell could possibly pick up the reins now? I've no idea?
I reckon Mr Jackson and Co are pretty gutted, as they should be.
I wait with baited breath More
Posted by willy d at 11:55 on 03 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Del Toro leaves The Hobbit |
Hellboy 3 anyone? More
Posted by Zaphod121 at 18:59 on 02 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Fingers crossed.... |
....three letters....McG.....omg! More
Posted by rantbot66 at 17:48 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: PETER JACKSON TO DIRECT THE HOBBIT |
#000000]l do it"]nbsp; &nbs p; ahoma] "Star Treck" Lukas June 1st 2010] More
Posted by shanek1980 at 13:50 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| PETER JACKSON TO DIRECT THE HOBBIT |
Who else could do it justice? More
Posted by boredbluekoala at 12:12 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Bummer! |
This is a bit of bad news! Del Toro is one of a very select group of people that i think could do the Hobbit justice - the only others i could see doing it are Peter Jackson rse),imi, Alex Proyas or Steven Spielberg. I'd personally like to see what Proyas could do with it, but if, as i expect, Raimi get's the gig - that would be good too! More
Posted by lukeyboy at 11:39 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Oh no! |
With Jackson originally handing over the reigns to Del Toro I felt in safe hands. Now with him backing out there can be only once choise, the first choise. Come on Peter, make The Hobbit. Please. More
Posted by XVII at 09:55 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| In the style of Darth Vader; |
Noooooooooo!
That is all. More
Posted by Mr Grizzly at 09:22 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| In the style of Darth Vader; |
Noooooooooo!
That is all. More
Posted by Mr Grizzly at 09:22 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Jackson's THE MAN |
I am really sorry to hear that he has gone, there is an obvious need for the visionary director of The Lord Of The Rings to pick up the reins and complete what is one of the best literery treasures of our modern age. No-one else can ensure that the look and feel of the new movies will match seamlessly into the trilogy already committed to celluloid, because remember this is all part of one huge journey and it should have continuity.
I understand theat Peter Jackson lived & breathed The Lord More
Posted by kittybinks at 07:55 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| love-in! |
Wow! Never have I witnessed such a display of mutual masturbation.... More
Posted by nickuk at 07:33 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
Sad, sad news indeed. Although if Hellboy 3 can make an appearance now, I wouldn't complain.
If Jackson is still not willing to do the right thing & direct himself then I think that Neill Blomkamp might be a good choice. District 9 was a triumph not only visually but as an original story & as a production overall. He already has Jackson's backing & has proved that he is a very creative director. By NO means should Sam Raimi even be considered for the job as I've not yet seen anythin More
Posted by Tenacious P at 00:54 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| New Director? |
How about Chris Weitz! Maybe he could work the same magic that he did on the 'His Dark Materials' franchise?
Ya think? More
Posted by Cynric at 00:39 on 01 June 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Hellboy 3 |
this really coulda been a contender.
nevermind; more Hellboy would go someway to making up for it. More
Posted by jamesjewell1983 at 23:30 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| What a weekend... |
First Mr. Hopper throws his leg over his iron horse and hits the highway to heaven and now Del Toro jacks Hobbit... it doesn't get much worse than this, well apart from empires top 50 video game character list. Hopefully Mr. Jackson will step in as I think he is the only director capable of giving middle earth back its magic... More
Posted by Greagoir at 22:10 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| No more Del Toro!!! |
I have to say i'm absolutely gutted that Del Toro is no longer directing, i think they guy is brilliant and i love all his movies, but aslong as someone like Michael Bay or Roland Emmerich doesn't replace him then i'm fairly confident that whoever does will do a great job.
Del Toro and Jackson have already laid the foundation of the movie with creature designs and screenplay etc they just need to start filming and soon!!! Hopefully this might sway Jackson to take the helm and bring us back to More
Posted by eddc1990 at 20:44 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: Del Toro Won't Direct The Hobbit |
They could give it to Paul Verhoeven. More
Posted by Jasper_29 at 20:35 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Give the gig to Alf (no, not the furry cat eating alien) |
Alfonso Curon for the job...he did a spanking good job with HP3 and Children of Men was a visual hoot as well. More
Posted by MaxRenn at 20:07 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| director? |
I'm worried about who will be up to the task - jackson no doubt could do it but im not sure he will - i don't think sam raimi could pull it off - he's good but ive nevr been a huge fan of the films hes directed - the hobbit needs someone really special! More
Posted by wenna_berry_23 at 18:59 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: Hobbit films |
Good for him for putting his foot down and sayin enough is enough. Maybe studios will realise these people will only take so much messing about. Gutted he's out, personally i'm hoping for Hellboy 3.
More
Posted by TheSpleen at 18:47 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: Hobbit films |
There are a TON of very good directors out there and everyone seems to want a guy who has an "off-the-wall" style, like Peter Jackson or Sam Raimi. How about someone who's not really connected to the Middle Earth idea but has had some success as a director? Chris Columbus might be a good choice if he's given a degree of control; Jonathan Frakes is a Star Trek guy, but I feel hr might be a good fit; or a big name (and I mean BIG name) , like Steven Spielberg, only because he would be th More
Posted by darkjediknightmare at 17:41 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| AFTER A FAIRLY SHITTY SESSION AT THE BOOKIES...... |
this depressing news caps off a fairly shitty bank holiday full stop. The administrative mess that is MGM would appear to have far reaching consequences. Jackson must plunge back into middle earth and save this thing now. How could he not? More
Posted by ROTGUT at 17:35 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: Somebody is going to regret this... |
I wonder if they would consider Juan Antonio Bayona, dierctor of The Orphanage, as a potential replacement? I could be beneficial to use someone Del Toro has a working relationship with. The same could equally be said for the Jackson/Neil Blomkamp connection
gn] More
Posted by Fit Kisto at 16:56 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Somebody is going to regret this... |
The only director more perfect for The Hobbit than Peter Jackson, was Del Toro. Somewhere down the line we'll be left wondering about this film that never was. When they get lumbered with some second-rate director. More
Posted by Jenzy at 15:28 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
Well al we have to do is wait until 2043 and then the books will become public domain. More
Posted by billythehick at 15:08 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| MCGGGGGGG |
Someone detain him, frame him for murder or something, just don't let him anywhere near this More
Posted by emperorglenuff at 13:38 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: RE: |
L: BOHEMIANBOB
L: plum bob
give it back to jackson!! end of!
ed.
Stop hiding behind the "producer" mask and step up to the plate...
agree, with this sad turn of events it's the only way to go.
It's tragic though, as Del Toro was the man for the job hands down. He really got the idea that The Hobbit has to look different yet feel like the same world, I loved how he talked about everything looking sort of golden. I think his two parter would have been quite More
Posted by The Todge at 13:09 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: oh well.... |
Peter Jackson is the only Director i want now . These 2 movies will make tons of money , surely you have to speculate to acumulate even in the movie biz ...... i think some guys at MGM are spineless from what i've read . More
Posted by Beno at 12:43 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: MGM |
L: Rgirvan44
I would rather he didn't do Hellboy 3. I love the first two films, but I would rather see GTD go off and do something new.
Personally At The Mountains Of Madness should happen - with all the adaptations of pulp sci-fi and fantasy from the early 20th century being made (Conan, John Carter from Mars etc) it is time for Lovecraft to get his due.
Also - interesting that James McAvoy joined the cast of X Men late last week. Wasn't he rumored to be up for the role of Bi More
Posted by Pigeon Army at 12:41 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| oh well.... |
Del Toro is extremely talented and had about 385 projects planned at one point! It'll be inetesrting to see what he goes after next. More
Posted by Snake-Eyes at 11:55 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Del Toro quits Hobbit |
This is pretty disappointing, I would have loved to see what he could have done with the film, Still with everything he was doing I guess something had to give, and the Hobbit wasn't getting anywhere fast. Good luck to him with whatever he does next
Maybe Jackson should pick up the reins, like others I really couldn't care less about Tintin The cinematic Middle Earth is very much his world, he should be the one to carry it forward
More
Posted by Scruffybobby at 11:52 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: MGM |
I would rather he didn't do Hellboy 3. I love the first two films, but I would rather see GTD go off and do something new.
Personally At The Mountains Of Madness should happen - with all the adaptations of pulp sci-fi and fantasy from the early 20th century being made (Conan, John Carter from Mars etc) it is time for Lovecraft to get his due.
Also - interesting that James McAvoy joined the cast of X Men late last week. Wasn't he rumored to be up for the role of Bilbo?
As for ne More
Posted by Rgirvan44 at 11:51 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: MGM |
Hows about we get a Hellboy 3 now? More
Posted by darth silas at 11:25 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
del Toro is my favourite director working today and as much as I love The Lord of the Rings and would be interested to see del Toro's take on this universe I'm quite glad that he has decided to leave the project. He has an abundance of original stories in hiswonderful mind and I think the sort of commitment required to direct the 2 Hobbit films would stifle his creativity somewhat. More
Posted by Biggus at 11:09 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: MGM |
L: jimoakley666
1- I'm chuffed. Not a fan of all that goblin shit. Never got the love for the Rings. But I am a big fan of Del Toro. This means we get more of his original stuff like Pan's and Devil's, that's great news. Can't wait to see his take on Frankenstein.
bsolutely agree.
More
Posted by UTB at 11:01 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
It's a heavy disappointment for sure, though anything that potentially accelerates a Lovecraftian project is a definite silver lining. More
Posted by herbertwest1701 at 10:30 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Del Crapo |
Personally I'm quite glad he has left the project. He could possible have made a really good film, but we'll never know. Jackson should just stop with all the bollocks and get behind the camera, as he truly is the only person who can make a great Hobbit film. Just how exactly were they going to get Del Toro's style to fit in with what Jackson had done with the l trilogy? Too quirky for my tastes (and if I'm honest, not all that good).
Again, I find frustration with Jackson's stance on why More
Posted by Alistair at 10:13 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
COME NOW MR JACKSON, AS HARD AS THE RINGS TRILOGY MUST HAVE BEEN TO DIRECT FOR SUCH A LONG TIME , ONLY YOU COULD DO THIS FILM JUSTICE, HELP US PETER JACKSON YOUR OUR ONLY HOPE. More
Posted by theonering at 10:12 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
Delighted, fucking delighted. The Devil's Backbone is good but every single movie he's made since then has been poor. Yes I'd include Pan's Labyrinth in that. Jesus Christ the fantasy was intrusive. Now lets hope common sense prevails and PJ gets behind the fucking camera. More
Posted by sephiroth7 at 09:45 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Sad news but you can hardly blame him |
Del Toro has so many projects stacked up that as a filmmaker he just cannot wait for MGM to sort themselves out anymore. I was really looking forward to The Hobbit under his direction but I guess this was a matter of time kind of situation.
I think Jackson will end up directing this himself; he's been developing it alongside Del Toro and considering all the pre-production work and script is done at this stage hiring another director would mean either someone who would work with all the existing More
Posted by Marwood at 09:45 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
This film is cursed. More
Posted by efc91 at 09:37 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| I'll bet... |
McG gets it! More
Posted by bradthunder at 09:32 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Least surprising news ever... |
And as much as I love GDT's work his english language endeavors have always felt vastly inferior to his other works to me. This could be a blessing in the long run. Come on Jackson, time to step up to the plate no? More
Posted by pete_traynor at 09:24 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
F$%# MGM! Someone sort these arses out for the sake of this film and Bond! Hope Jackson takes the directors chair. More
Posted by steveg66 at 09:07 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Excellent news! |
It's been a hard slog for Del Toro, but at least this sets him free to make other films- there were so many tantaslising options he had set up before this came along. Most of them are probably unavailable now, but Frankenstein, Tarzan, Mountains of Madness... maybe a smaller film like Cronos or Pan's Labyrinth... that'd be good. Anyway, this is exciting because Del Toro is free of the ring! More
Posted by sweetladybrick at 09:02 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: |
L: plum bob
give it back to jackson!! end of!
ed.
Stop hiding behind the "producer" mask and step up to the plate... More
Posted by BOHEMIANBOB at 08:51 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
give it back to jackson!! end of! More
Posted by plum bob at 08:37 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| A Noble Sacrifice |
Definitely a good personal decision on Del Toro's part, but heartbreaking nonetheless. Del Toro has been one of my favourite filmmakers since the late 90s, and it's been wonderful to see his star rising over the past decade - so when he got The Hobbit gig, I was very very excited. That said, I always had a few reservations - thus far, Del Toro's English-language films have suffered in comparison to his Spanish-language projects (although I do love the Hellboy films, even as a 'fundamentalist' f More
Posted by marlowe9 at 08:33 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
great news.... maybe the mountains of madness or Hellboy 3 will come sooner this way. i beginning to get tired of all the bureauocratical BS tied to this film and bond 23, so probably a good personal move for him. still, good to hear of his continued involvement, whatever the capacity. More
Posted by Nalfeshnee at 06:42 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Lets still remember |
At the mountains of madness and his other projects will come sooner this way
But watching The Lord of the Rings the other day I was starting to get really excited about this More
Posted by monkeyhumour at 06:31 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
sad day... More
Posted by angier21 at 06:19 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| THE HOBBIT |
only Del Torro can direct The Hobbit if it's to be the best movie it can be. More
Posted by IRISHKNIGHT110 at 03:33 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Jackson or Raimi |
Pete should just roll his sleeves up and direct this one himself; with Del Toro doing a big chunk of the workload in pre-production, surely that will have given Jackson enough of a break? Failing that, Sam Raimi - a big influence on Bad Taste-era Jackson - should be given a chance. The perfect consolation prize for being screwed over by Sony and Marvel. More
Posted by Garth_Marenghi at 03:18 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Doomed I Say! |
If they hire either Sam Raimi or Neill Blomkamp, the thing may still be salvageable. Otherwise, this is pretty much doomed More
Posted by lona_no_friends at 03:12 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
Perhaps it's time for MGM to fall on its sword and sell the movie rights to the Hobbit... More
Posted by Kmadden2004 at 01:46 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| MGM |
1- I'm chuffed. Not a fan of all that goblin shit. Never got the love for the Rings. But I am a big fan of Del Toro. This means we get more of his original stuff like Pan's and Devil's, that's great news. Can't wait to see his take on Frankenstein.
2- MGM get your fucking arses into gear. If Daniel Craig pisses off from Bond due to these pricks I will be very VERY sore. What the hell are they doing, for god's sake? More
Posted by jimoakley666 at 01:01 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: Neill Blomkamp |
This is very disappointing news....
Whilst I liked the Tolken books (Rings & the Hobbit), it was the prospect of Del Toro creating his vision for middle earth that had me salivating. So to hear that he has departed the project is a massive blow to the future films and I for one won't be anticipating them anywhere near as much now this has transpired.
More
Posted by Qwerty Norris at 00:51 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Neill Blomkamp |
As new director.
You know it makes sense. More
Posted by Martin1876 at 00:50 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| RE: sadness |
L: Walt Flanagan
what a waste of talent....
It is awful when big business gets in the way of art...
ouldn't agree more. After watching Pan's Labyrinth and even Hellboy II, I was so stoked for seeing this under Del Toro's creative direction. Now that will cease to be :( More
Posted by Noelg25 at 00:46 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
Well after all this time, I'm kinda stunned he stuck it out this long as with the guy being at the peak of his life creatively, to not know just when he would be able to film must have killed him for a long time. The Hobbit will be fine with Jackson co-producing, the screenplays are done and now Del Toro can do what he loves: actually MAKE movies. More
Posted by badassmofo at 00:44 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| Bit of a disaster for Jackson and co... |
Understandable why GDT left, but it's a big blow to the project. More
Posted by Dirty Hartigan at 00:37 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
|
Well after all this time, I'm kinda stunned he stuck it out this long as with the guy being at the peak of his life creatively, to not know just when he would be able to film must have killed him for a long time. The Hobbit will be fine with Jackson co-producing, the screenplays are done and now Del Toro can do what he loves: actually MAKE movies. More
Posted by badassmofo at 00:36 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| sadness |
what a waste of talent....
It is awful when big business gets in the way of art... More
Posted by Walt Flanagan at 00:35 on 31 May 2010 | Report This Post |
 |
|
 |
| |