|RE: unreadable and yawn|
|if you don't like it then keep it to yourself 'cause we do More|
Posted by jaakhumparies at 11:52 on 17 August 2011 | Report This Post
|not tom cruize for f***s sake he's the exact opposite of Jack Reacher and if you think he will be good 'cause of mission impossible... the Jack Reacher series is nothing like Mission impossible! I don't think they could have chosen a worse choice to play him! which book are they making, anyway? if it's 61 hours maybe tom is playing the bad guy.
how is Jack Reacher a short twig with a black broom on his head, he's a 6'4" heap of muscle with a blonde crew cut, for goodness sake! More|
Posted by jaakhumparies at 11:42 on 17 August 2011 | Report This Post
|No Way Tom Cruise!!|
|.........just heard this rumour........say it ain't so.............. More|
Posted by tmacie at 12:02 on 18 July 2011 | Report This Post
| RE: Just Say NO!|
JUST SAY NO!
www.petitionspot.com/petitions/TomIsNotReachert is an online petition to at least try to dissuade Cruise from doing Reacher this terrible injustice. It doesn't matter who you think is right for the role I think every single Reacher fan agrees Cruise is just - he's just - ughhhhh AHUGH UGH BHGUDH..... Sorry about that - I've just vomited with impotant rage at the thought of it!
Posted by The Rainford at 03:22 on 23 June 2011 | Report This Post
|Someone is gone Bananas in Hollywood|
|TOM CRUISE, JACK REACHER, since when does a midget get to play the part of a giant, is this a joke, or are you trying to make a joke out of Lee Child's, JACK REACHER. Put Cruise on,movie will failed with the FANS!!!! More|
Posted by rdnsfer at 13:44 on 18 June 2011 | Report This Post
| i could not agree with you more. Ray Stevenson is always the person i picture when im reading the novels. More|
Posted by Mr. Orange at 22:41 on 21 May 2011 | Report This Post
|Who I picture when i read Reacher novels|
|I dont know about anyone else, but when I read the Reacher novels, I always picture Ray Stevenson, (Rome, Book of Eli, Thor, etc). He's exactly the right height, tough as ol' boots, and is a very good actor. (Not to mention he's built like a brick sh.... out house). For me there's no one else it could be. Tom Hardy: too young, Hugh Jackman: too short, Gerard Butler: all of the above plus crap actor.
Whoever they choose, all i care is that they are capable of doing the character justice. Reacher More|
Posted by Mr. Orange at 22:38 on 21 May 2011 | Report This Post
|It needs to be an unknown actor who is between 6"4 and 6"6. I'm a professional actor and I'm an avid reader of the series. Originally I didn't want there to be any films made of the books because the way I build the scene and the characters in my head is perfect to me, and it will be completely different to everybody else's perception, but everybody will see it the way they want to see it using their own interpretation. A film would give us a definite article, and it wouldn't be perfec More|
Posted by Diezel16N at 19:35 on 06 April 2011 | Report This Post
|Nobody has mentioned Gerard Butler. He'd do the role justice. I'm just about to start reading 61 hours, I hope it is as good as the last few I've read. One Shot got me hooked on Reacher. More|
Posted by greenybobs at 22:03 on 02 November 2010 | Report This Post
| RE: Jack Reacher Headed To Screen|
| Liam Neeson. More|
Posted by boisy67 at 14:59 on 03 October 2010 | Report This Post
|Lots of good names, but you have all missed one|
|Hugh Jackman could play the role well but he is just too good looking, not nearly rough enough. Honestly I think we should all consider David Boreanaz. Sure he played a goody two shoes vamp in Buffy but he seriously kicked ass in "Bones". I can't think of a better actor to play the role and do it well. If David isn't picked it would have to be an unknown actor, but please no one form the world of wrestling or ultimate fighting. We want justice being done to the character of Reacher. More|
Posted by uknowiknow at 05:28 on 09 September 2010 | Report This Post
|I THINK TOM HARDY SHOULD PLAY REACHER I THINK HES PERFECT More|
Posted by angel_skf at 12:00 on 23 July 2010 | Report This Post
| Jane, was in The Punisher. Right size, hes got the right look too. If anyones seen him in Hung, you'll think hes perfect. More|
Posted by F62N1 at 07:08 on 13 July 2010 | Report This Post
|Ray Stevenson from punisher 2 and Rome series. He's tall enough and right age. I think he would be a perfect Jack Reacher.
Posted by dodds1875 at 01:58 on 16 June 2010 | Report This Post
|Has to be an MMA guy|
|Frank Mir would be perfect. Has the size, the looks, the attitude, the skills. More|
Posted by bud_tugly at 07:02 on 23 May 2010 | Report This Post
| RE: Jack Reacher Headed To Screen|
| I'm a massive fan of this series and I'm afraid that most of you are way off the mark...
Clint Eastwood??? Even as a young man he would never be right for Reacher. Yes, he's got the attitude but not the size. Jack Reacher's size is a major part of his character which must make it to the screen intact to be authentic. Very few of the actors mentioned have it.
Out of all the suggestions Jackman is probably the best but he still falls short. Just maybe if he's beefe More|
Posted by davido757 at 17:36 on 19 April 2010 | Report This Post
| RE: Jack Reacher Headed To Screen|
| If we are talking really Tall, Blonde with Blue eyes then True Blood's Alexander Skarsgård should be a contender. The look would be right but as he hasn't been in much it is hard to tell his range as an actor.
I didn't see him in HBO's Generation Kill, but at he has experiance playing military. More|
Posted by Polgara30 at 16:08 on 16 April 2010 | Report This Post
|Finally going to bring Reacher to the bing screen, just hope who ever is involved does the writing and feel of the books justice. As for who would play the man himself, i'd like to put Josh Holloway(Sawyer form Lost) forward as a very suitable choice, he'd nned a hair cut and to put on a few pounds, but i'm sure he could do a good job. More|
Posted by DaveM14 at 21:13 on 04 April 2010 | Report This Post
|I know he's only like 30, but i think Jared Padalecki could do it very well if they lost the floppy hair and roughed him up a bit. Check out him in Supernatural and you might get what i mean. he's huge prob the 6'5 mark, and has this rough gravelly voice. a bit of makeup and he could be 40. That or the guy from watchmen, the Comedian More|
Posted by crash2burn at 02:26 on 29 March 2010 | Report This Post
|Jack Reacher = Hugh Jackman|
|Hugh Jackman is perfect to play reacher. Almost. Statham is wrong, Bruce Willis is wrong; both have the wrong look and are not tall enough. Eastwood would have been perfect as a younger man. It is hard to get it dead on right when casting a book character- ask whoever cast Matthew McConaughey as Dirk Pitt- I think Jackman would do the character justice. To anyone who dislikes the Mr Childs writing; well, writing style is like directorial style- some love Spielberg, some hate him, and it is the s More|
Posted by Mort Grimm at 12:27 on 19 March 2010 | Report This Post
|Jack Reacher Headed to Screen|
|I'm a Jack Reacher "totally committed" fan. I've read every book and each time I think it's better then the last. I cannot, for the life of me, understand why a movie or at least a TV series has not been created on the Reacher character. Reacher is a unique character that would be interesting to both men and certainly women. I think a totally new actor should play Reacher and it would have to be someone with military experience so it would be authentic. I would love to see someon More|
Posted by scrapqueen at 03:57 on 26 September 2009 | Report This Post
|There can be only one|
|As a massive fan of the entire series I think one shot would be the logical choice to introduce movie fans to the theme that Lee Child has created, as it's a short story that will translate well to the screen. For me I feel the author had Clint Eastwood in mind when he wrote this character as the no nonesense attitude of a man that retaliates only when provoked while always doing the morally right thing in the end reflects Dirty Harry, of that I have no doubt.
Given that time has moved on I sus More|
Posted by Strider_surely at 09:27 on 05 September 2009 | Report This Post
|what about your man there dougary scott, he kinda looks mean sometimes, i think he might be good. or what about hugh jackman, he's 6'3 they just make him look small in x-men, im sure they could make him look 6'5 easily More|
Posted by stewballs at 17:17 on 13 June 2009 | Report This Post
|read every book.can't see any actor who could play him.but there is a rugby player from englands world cup winning team called lawrence d'allaglio who is 6'5'' built perfectly and 38 yrs old.wish he could act. More|
Posted by stefmurray at 02:19 on 08 June 2009 | Report This Post
|i think Richard Burgi is perfect for the role, for those that don't know who he is...he's plays the ex husband (karl mayer) of Terri Hatcher on desperate housewives
http://www.buddytv.com/articles/Image/des perate-housewives-characters/Richard-Burgi-as-Karl-Maye r.jpg
he is tall and and absolute tank! i think he's got the charm of what i would expect Reacher to have too! More|
Posted by screaming_69 at 13:40 on 11 February 2009 | Report This Post
| I always imagine Dominic Purcell from Prison Break when I'm reading them. But I quite like Aaron Eckhart too. Both are too short in real life, but they could employ some LOTR style trickery. More|
Posted by Jonnyp41 at 16:18 on 13 January 2009 | Report This Post
|Yep.. this is a tough one... I'd have to say Kyle Chandler (bombsquad guy from Greys Anatomy - coach Taylor Friday Night Lights). He is the right size, and with a bit of ruggedification (!!) would be perfect... (well unless Jason Statham can grow 5") More|
Posted by Chelseafan at 23:39 on 04 January 2009 | Report This Post
| RE: FInally, casting will be difficult....|
| t to agree, Vince Vaughn is too comedic to play reacher and has not the physical size for the character and if they find the right person to play reacher they should start with the enemy not one shot because i hate prequels. More|
Posted by anakin solo at 13:38 on 10 October 2008 | Report This Post
|FInally, casting will be difficult....|
|I'm a huge fan of the books, but there are much better books earlier in the series that would make great films, i thought the same about Clive Cusslers Dirk Pitt adventures, but they have been done terribly to date. Would have been excellent with the right cast and adaption!!!
If the casting is right, they stay faithfull to the story and atmosphere of the books I think this will be a great film and hopefully spawn sequels or prequels too!!
An unknown or non type-cast actor would be perfect More|
Posted by oz_p at 17:08 on 06 October 2008 | Report This Post
| RE: Who is Jack Reacher?|
| o not the rock just because he's the same kinda character in walking tall, personally i don't think that the rock played the same character at all, just no. No matter how you spin it no one can play reacher. More|
Posted by anakin solo at 15:46 on 01 October 2008 | Report This Post
|Who is Jack Reacher?|
|Any ideas on who could seriously play him? He needs to be 6'5" so it rules out Statham who is 5'10". The only current actor who is tall enough and big enough would be The Rock! I think he could play it with the same sort of character he was in Walking Tall. More|
Posted by Tyler Soze at 10:34 on 30 September 2008 | Report This Post
|I love these books, they're just f**king ace to put it bluntly; and One Shot, is one of the best in the series. I just pray they pull it off, casting wise, it's going to be pretty tricky. If the guy who played Clark Kent in the latest superman movie was blonde and a little rougher round the edges and older, he'd be perfect! More|
Posted by tysmuse2 at 21:41 on 28 September 2008 | Report This Post
|as with and earlier post, Clint Eastwood would be the only logical choice ( ideally Heartbreak Ridge Era) Jason Statham is way too small and english!! More|
Posted by juleswinfield at 20:39 on 28 September 2008 | Report This Post
|their is no one on this earth who could play jack reacher and lee child should not allow paramount to ruin his book, like they did with the robert crais book- hostage. The writing in his books is brilliant and i've been hooked on each story that he has wriiten as i've read each book in the series. More|
Posted by anakin solo at 14:10 on 27 September 2008 | Report This Post
|Sounds like he could be a dead ringer for Dolph Lundgren!
Let's hope not though eh. More|
Posted by evildave69 at 04:12 on 27 September 2008 | Report This Post
|Statham could probably do a decent job, other than that they could give Vince McMahon a call and see if any of the pituitary retards he has working for him are concealing acting talents!!!!! More|
Posted by ovverbruv at 16:59 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|I always imagined Reacher to be like Lawrence Dallaglio but with a less beat up face. I think he needs to be played by an unknown actor though. Of all the current actors i'd prob go with Statham. More|
Posted by burgans at 16:48 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|i've read a few of these books and always thought it would be great to see them on the big screen. I will agree that from time to time the quality of the writing is a bit odd, but The Da Vinci Code was bloody terribly written and look where that book went. More|
Posted by clarkkent at 16:23 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
| RE: Reacher at last|
| And of course, there's the samll fact that A History of Violence was actually written by comics legend John Wagner, and adapted by yer man.
But hey! Don't let little things like facts get in the way. More|
Posted by raclements at 15:05 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|Reacher at last|
|This role was ideal for Clint Eastwood 30 yrs ago
Would like to see Jason Statham or Stone Cold Steve Austen!!! More|
Posted by stevie 1 at 14:54 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|Lee Child's writing is near unreadable.
"Reacher said nothing".
Every 2 lines.
"Reacher said nothing".
Posted by Boutros at 14:18 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|The potential is there|
|There is a wealth of plot material to mine from these books. This could turn into a massive series. Just hope they stick with the same actor for Jack Reacher, rather than complicating things like they did with Tom Clancy's Jack Ryan (Alec Baldwin, Harrison Ford and then BEN AFFLECK!!!) More|
Posted by muchobenny at 13:52 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|But who to play him?
Physically we are talking about someone the size of Dolph Lundgren, but please god tell me there is a better actor around.
When they released "Kiss the Girls" I was worried about Morgan Freeman as Alex Cross is also supposed to be huge, and, although Freeman bows to no-one in acting skill the films were missing something of Alex Cross by putting a diminuative man in the role. More|
Posted by ovverbruv at 13:17 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|Patzw, jasonbourne.cs and Tyler Soze are spot on.
loved the books, loads of action great character who ends up being in the wrong place more times than John McClane.
Posted by Tosh at 12:00 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|These are great books. They are fun to read and would be great fun to see on screen. More|
Posted by Tyler Soze at 10:37 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|Mediocre and hammy writing - Jack Reacher is a caricature. Harry Bosch should hit the big screen before bloody Reacher. I say again, YAWN!
Although...Bourne was a tacky little series on paper and look what happened there. More|
Posted by Youshouldberunning at 09:17 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|couldn't agree more patzw
with an excellent back catalogue of books they could make for an awesome series of movies More|
Posted by jasonbourne.cs at 09:13 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post
|About bloody time! More|
Posted by patzw at 08:49 on 26 September 2008 | Report This Post