Join Empire | Log In RSS  |  Twitter  |  Facebook  |  iPhone App
The Empire office TV is switched off. Empire Magazine
Search   
Empire Magazine
Join Empire
Get our free weekly newsletter

 
Oscars 2010 Microsite
Coverage of the 82nd Academy Awards
X-Files Season 1
Subscribe to Empire magazine today

Movie News

LATEST HEADLINES
TODAY
Want To Be A Mark Millar Villain?
You can be the nemesis in Nemesis
Chris Nolan Overseeing Superman?
He’ll "mentor" a new film's development
Anyone For An Audrey Tautou Film?
Well, Charlie Winston music video...
24 Movie Edges Ever Nearer
Billy Ray in talks with Fox to write
Tim Robbins Up For Green Lantern
He's playing Senator Hammond
Matt Damon Suffers Contagion
Steven Soderbergh sets up another film
Peter Bogdanovich Plans New Film
Adaptation of Turn Of The Century
Katherine Heigl Takes One For The Money
She may be going bounty hunting…
Weisz Has The Keys To Dream House
Starring with Daniel Craig & Naomi Watts
Hugh Laurie Picking Oranges?
He's considering a comedy drama
Tom Felton Joins The Apparition
He'll try to help Ashley Greene
Fichtner And Heard Drive Angry
More cast for Lussier road rage
Neil Jordan's Ondine Online
Trailer for Farrell fantasy
More Movie News

24 June 2009
The Oscars Set To Get Even Longer
Best Picture race to feature 10 nominees
Source: Oscars.org

The Oscars Set To Get Even Longer

Just when you thought the Oscars ceremony couldn’t possibly get any longer, the Academy Of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences today announced plans to increase the number of films in the Best Picture category from five to ten.

“Having 10 Best Picture nominees is going allow Academy voters to recognize and include some of the fantastic movies that often show up in the other Oscar categories, but have been squeezed out of the race for the top prize,” said Sid Ganis, president of the Academy.

There’s a general feeling that the Academy has taken this decision in the wake of heavy criticism over the exclusion of The Dark Knight from last year’s Best Picture race. There was also some speculation that the Best Animated Feature category might now be cancelled as a result, with the wider field allowing Pixar films, for example, to enter the running.

But that category remains, with Ganis claiming that the expansion was also taken as a way to return to the Oscars’ roots – the first 16 Academy Awards all featured more than five Best Picture nominees. The last ceremony to do so was in 1943, when Casablanca won the big prize.

“The final outcome, of course, will be the same – one Best Picture winner – but the race to the finish line will feature 10, not just five, great movies from 2009,” added Ganis. “I can’t wait to see what that list of ten looks like when the nominees are announced in February.”

Well, one thing’s for sure – Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen won’t be on that list, unless they expand the category to include 1000 films. And probably not even then.

What’s Empire’s feeling on this? Well, it’s hard not to feel that this is purely a cosmetic change, and something of a condescending one at that; a way of patting films like The Dark Knight on the head and saying, ‘see? You made it to the final ten! Well done! Now run along and play, while the real movies vie for the big award’. After all, the argument is clear: if a film didn’t get enough votes to make the top five nominations, then it doesn’t stand a chance of winning.

But maybe we’ll be pleasantly surprised. After all, you’ve got to be in it to win it, and had The Dark Knight been in the running last year, things may – just may – have been slightly different.

One thing's for sure, though: with ten Best Picture nominations to get through, bring a cushion for next year's event. You're going to need it.
 

Chris Hewitt

Have Your Say...
We want to know what you think? To have your say on this, and all of Empire's news stories, register here or login now.


Previous Story
Another Runaway For Stewart And Fanning
Halloween girl Taylor-Compton joins band
Next Story
Blood: The Last Vampire Exclusive Clip
Schoogirl slaying bloodsucking nasties

Advertisement


Your Comments
RE: RE:
L: James2183 As long as they acknowledge animated and films in the list then it should work out okayise we are going to have a pretty bland list of average films.  I doubt that's going to happen to be honest. BBCi has a quote that the ten will include "more populist films." ... Read More

FritzlFan About me

16:32, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
RE: RE:
L: MOTH This has absolutely nothing to do with quality, fairness, etc -as usual it's driven by money. Oscar-nominated films on general release at time of nominations (ie most of them) can generally expect anywhere from 25% - 75% increase in box-office in the month following the nominations, through a combination of increased screenings and increased ticket sales. (Eg last year Slumdog, The Reader and Frost/Nixon all took almost twice as much money in the 3 weeks following nomination... Read More

Professor Moriarty About me

15:14, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
RE: RE:
L: baerrtt Sid Ganis has admitted THE DARK KNIGHT snub led to this, sp; Sorry - they're changing the rules because a film that shouldn't have made the final 10 wasn't in it? Idiots - why don't they just make base it on box office if they are so desperate to improve their ratings by nominating films that don't deserve it. Bet he was gutted Mamma Mia didn't make it either ... Read More

elab49 About me

15:03, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
RE: RE:
As long as they acknowledge animated and foreign films in the list then it should work out okay. Otherise we are going to have a pretty bland list of average films.  ... Read More

James2183 About me

15:00, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
RE: RE:
posted this elsewhere before seeing this thread   This has absolutely nothing to do with quality, fairness, etc -as usual it's driven by money. Oscar-nominated films on general release at time of nominations (ie most of them) can generally expect anywhere from 25% - 75% increase in box-office in the month following the nominations, through a combination of increased screenings and increased ticket sales. (Eg last year Slumdog, The Reader and Frost/Nixon all took almost twice as... Read More

MOTH About me

14:31, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
RE:
I'm in favour of this and quite frankly they never should have chopped it down from 10 to five. Would LE GRANDE ILLUSION or THE ADVENTURES OF ROBIN HOOD have been nominated for Best Picture if the five film rule had been in place back then? Think through the years and ponder how many genuinely great films were left off the Best Picture list because of that change in the early 40s. I do and think back to years like 1999 where we could (and probably would) have seen BEING JOHN MALKOLVITCH, THE MA... Read More

baerrtt About me

12:44, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
So Saw VI (or whatever number it's up to) should be in with a chance then!! Animation should keep it's own category, some, deservedly so to me, should have got Best Picture. But voting snobbery will never let this happen (particularly if BAFTA try the same thing) ... Read More

steveg66 About me

11:22, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
RE: The Oscars Set To Get Even Longer
Although this is a good idea to include more films, there still is only one Oscar - so it will just make it harder to decide on a winner. They could split it like the Golden Globes and have one for Drama and one for Comedy/Musicals instead. Or, they could stop nominating films like jamin Button or The Reader (it was a truely brilliant performance by Kate Winslet, but Wall-E was a better film). Personally, I think that a Best Ensemble Cast Oscar would be a lot better than 10 BP nominees - i... Read More

MovieAddict247 About me

09:25, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
What about the categories that tend to go hand in hand with BP? Are there going to be 10 Best Director nominations too? If not then surely given the recent trend of BP films also being nominated for BD it will become very obvious which are the 'real' nominations. There are already 10 best Screenplay nominations, but would they extend this to 10 of each? ... Read More

DanBarnes501 About me

09:21, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
RE: The Oscars Set To Get Even Longer
I think Ice Age 3 is having the chance! ... Read More

Timmy_Brisby_05 About me

09:15, 25 June 2009 | Report This Post
Next Page

SUBSCRIBE TO EMPIRE
Subscribe To Empire Magazine
Subscribe And Get X-Files Season 1 DVD
Get the entire first season of the classic sci-fi series on DVD when you subscribe to Empire magazine!


CURRENT HIGHLIGHTS
Colin Firth on A Single Man
The Oscar nominee discusses his stunning latest role

Benicio del Toro on The Wolfman
The star talks delays, reshoots and getting furry...

10 Egregious Oscar Snubs
The worthy contenders that the Academy overlooked

Celebrity Stars In Their Eyes
The winners and losers when actors play real people

Movie Poster Mashups #56
Browse your iPod, iPad and Apple-related movie poster mashups


Back | Print This Page | Email This Page | Back To Top

EXCLUSIVE OFFERS
Free X-Files Season 1
Free when you subscribe to Empire
Subscribe Today »
Magazine Special Offers
Special offers on your favourite magazines
Latest Offers »
The Empire iPhone App
Every Empire film review at your fingertips
Click here »
 
Movie News  |  Empire Blog  |  Movie Reviews  |  Future Films  |  Features  |  Video Interviews  |  Image Gallery  |  Competitions  |  Forum  |  Magazine  |  Resources  |  Free Movies
 
Mojo4music  |  Q4Music  |  Kerrang!  |  Aloud.com  |  Kiss
 
© Bauer Consumer Media | Terms And Conditions | Our Data Promise To You | Contact Us | Empire FAQ
Bauer Consumer Media. Company number 1176085 (England). Registered Office: 21 Holborn Viaduct, London EC1A 2DY