After losing the woman of his dreams, Anderson (Biggs) is convinced he'll never fall in love again. But at the urging of his best friend, he spontaneously proposes to a dissatisfied waitress named Katie (Fisher) and an innocent dare evolves into the kind of love that both have been looking for all along.
Jason Biggs is back, and it turns out that’s a good thing. The most successful pie seducer in movie history is using his mojo on an object more worthy of his attentions, and the result is a comedy with genuine charm. Biggs plays a sadsack who proposes to a waitress (Isla Fisher) to settle a bet with his best friend. When she says yes, the pair muddle through a series of obstacles — including randy parents, escaped convicts, arrest and circus performers — on their way to (maybe) true love. There’s little or no originality, but sufficient laugh-out-loud moments to make this an entertaining little effort, while Fisher is as cute as an entire button shop in her first major leading role.
It may be preditable stuff but it's truly charming in places.