Gimli The Dwarf
Posts: 73480
Joined: 30/9/2005 From: Central Park Zoo
|
The last few films I've seen Positives -Some incredible battle sequence. They come quite close to Saving Private Ryan with regards to realism and horror -Two solid central performances, particularly from Dong-Kun Jang as the elder brother. -A story which shows atrocities being commited by both sides in the war, giving a relatively unbiased view Negatives -A bit patchy in places. It sometimes felt like scenes changed too abruptly, without giving the earlier scene time to finish. -The drama and friction between the two brothers was nicely played for the most part, but sometimes became overwrought. -As good as they are, the battle scenes occasionally lacked tension and the fast editing created confusion Overall, an excellent war-film, a well-deserved 4/5 Postives -Some genuinely gruesome and inventive set pieces. -A tongue-in-cheek sense of humour. Never really took itself too seriously. Negatives -By this time we all know the formula for these films, and very little changed in this one, giving it a tremendous sense of predictability. -The initial rollercoaster crash sequence had some alarmingly shoddy CGI work. -The overall idea behind this, a rollercoaster disaster, doesn't have the same level of shock value as the two major incidents in the previous film. This was never destined to become a classic, and is the weakest of the trilogy. Although it has many flaws it still provides a decent level of silly entertainment, and that can never be a bad thing - 3/5 Positives -A generally fantastic cast. Leonardo DiCaprio, Matt Damon, Martin Sheen, Alec baldwin, Vera Farmiga and Mark Wahlberg all shine, even when only given little screen time. -Some terrifically brutal and gory sequences. The sight and sound of a bullet to the head has rarely been so effective. -A great balance between bloody shootouts and the calmer, more emotional moments. Negatives -For all the plaudits recievd by Jack Nicholson, it still isn't a great Nicholson performance. He is good, but seemed wildly over-the-top to bring a great level of menace to the role. -A few dodgy accents from time to time, Ray Winstone in particular. -The film is being hailed as a return to form for Scorsese. It certainly is very good, but his last effort, The Aviator, was a better picture. Still, this a problem with overall perception of the film and not the film itself. An extremely entertainig thrill-ride with a good story at it's centre - 4/5 I'm still useless at stuff like this, particularly with the negative aspect.
_____________________________
So, sir, we let him have it right up! And I have to report, sir, he did not like it, sir. Fellow scientists, poindexters, geeks. Yeah, Mr. White! Yeah, science! Much more better!
|