MovieAddict247
Posts: 3359
Joined: 5/6/2009
|
I think - if they were Christmas Number One but weren't at all festive, Christmassy or at all seasonal, then no. quote:
ORIGINAL: Rhubarb There's loads of Christmas number ones that aren't christmassy, I would say no to them all if I was running this. But then I'd probably say no to wintery ones as well. It would be nice if, y'know a Christmas song won the Christmas poll. But would you class songs like Winter Wonderland, or Let it Snow, as winter songs then? Because they don't mention Christmas at all, yet I'd say they were definately Christmas songs. As Rawlinson says, so many Christmas songs aren't about Christmas. quote:
ORIGINAL: rawlinson I think including wintery ones makes sense, just because otherwise you might get a lot of people struggling to fill lists, but most of the actual Christmas number ones are, as you say, not about Christmas. I think a Christmas one will still walk it though. Probably Fairytale because everyone (except Gimli) likes it or a carol (In the Bleak Midwinter ftw). And if Christmas number ones are allowed then you're basically allowing some of the worst shit ever recorded - The Blobby song, Military Wives, Alexandra Burke's cover of Hallelujah, Bohemian Rhapsody... On the plus side we could all vote for a couple of Beatles songs and the Pet Shop Boys cover of Always on My Mind. That, or God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen.
_____________________________
VOTE NOW for your favourite vocalist - Empire's Favourite Voices
|