Chis
Posts: 13
Joined: 16/12/2005
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: ericcoyle To answer a previous question, no, X2 was not a great movie, nor even a good one. Singer's films are dull, dull, dull and this is the worst news possible for the X franchise. Why people persist in holding 1&2 up as some kind of standard is beyond me. They come across as dull TV movies with deeply inadequate action, dull one-on-one fights (boring) and worst of all have created this stupid idea of a love affair between Jean and Wolverine, side tracking Cyclops to an also ran role. What a jyp! I hope the new Wolverine can make us forget how terribly disappointing those first two film are. That's your opinion dude and fair enough. I agree X-1 wasn't that great, showed promise but lacked the polish & investment it needed. Though I thought X-2 was great, I rate it higher than First Class though I rate that a lot higher than X-1 & the god awful X-3. I thought the action scenes in First Class were far more dull, the Banshee & Angel fight scene made me cringe & made people laugh out loud in cinema I was in. Also X-2 didn't make up the Logan & Jean love affair, that has always been in the comics. But yeah, Cyclops got jyped, I agree with that. There is a good reason people hail X-2 in high regard, because most people thought it was a good movie, was well received by critics & fans when it came out and paved the way for the comic book films we have now..... though depending on the film, that could be a good or bad thing ha. And yes, please please please please let The Wolverine be a great film! Origins was terrible!! To sum up; X-men 1 = Meh ok X-men 2 = Great X-men 3 = Shit Origins: Wolverine = Shit First Class = Good
|