Olaf
Posts: 23364
Joined: 26/2/2007 From: 41°N 93°W
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Rinc quote:
ORIGINAL: Olaf It was a rhetorical question about Barca - my point is that it's impossible to dominate the CL and relatively speaking, Ferguson's European record is as good as anyone's. Any top European team you care to name has roughly the same record in the same time span; Real Madrid have been in three finals since the introduction of the CL, Milan, Bayern Munich and Juventus have been in four, Ajax have been in two (Munich and Ajax being another two teams who can be said to have dominated their respective leagues in the period). The Champions League is also way harder to win than the old European Cup was, so that should be taken into account before comparing Ferguson to 50s Real/70s-80s Liverpool/early-70s Munich/etc. But Ferguson's record isn't as good as anyone's given his domestic dominance. Out of those teams you've listed, and discounting Ajax because they just don't have the resources the others do, only Bayern have dominated their domestic league as much as Man U. And Bayern are well known as bottlers who haven't converted talent into European success. The CL may be harder to win than the European Cup but it's easier to get into and given Man Utd's players and resources, a QF place should be a definite every year. quote:
ORIGINAL: Olaf I don't mean to be coming off as a Ferguson fanboy or anything (I can't stand him to be honest), but the claim that he's underperformed in Europe doesn't hold up when you consider the realities of the tournament itself. It does hold up. Man Utd have dominated their domestic league more than any other major European power apart from Bayern in the last 20 years. In that time Man Utd have never finished outside of the top 3 and have resources most big clubs can only dream of. And yet there has never been a time when you could say Man Utd have been the best club in Europe over a 3-5 year period. Even in the last 5 years, when Man Utd have been their most consistent in the CL in reaching the final (and yet still went out in the group stage in those 5 years), there has always been the shadow of other teams who are held in higher regard hovering over them. Before those 5 years Man Utd reached only one final in 15 years. Most people at the time said Man Utd had failed to reach their potential in Europe and I think it can still be said. I can understand where you're coming from, but I just can't agree when there's been no team to dominate the Champions League in the way you're describing. You can point to domestic dominance, but it's totally arbitrary when it comes to European football (which is what my point with the wall of text about Barcelona was). Being the best in a league means nothing except being better than the other teams in that country, and has no correlation to being the best team in Europe. The PL was well behind the Serie A and La Liga throughout the 90s and the early 00s as well, so that needs to be taken into consideration. And during the period in the mid/late-00s where English football became the dominant force, they were the most successful English team in the tournament (along with Liverpool). The only time in the history of the CL where one team has been the best in Europe for a number of years in a row is recently with Barcelona, and even then they haven't won it back to back. The domestic dominance argument only holds water when it was the European Cup and only the league champions qualified, which is why Liverpool were able to win a much smaller tournament repeatedly during a period in which they bossed the English game as well. Other than that, it's just too difficult to have a monopoly on European success, and that's nothing to do with domestic leagues. If you take Ferguson's record in Europe in what it should be based on - his performances in Europe, and not about how he 'should have done' - then it's roughly as good as Real Madrid (six consecutive round of 16 exits from 04/05 to 09/10), Barcelona (the aforementioned five early exits), Bayern Munich (four) or A.C. Milan (five). If these teams aren't the closest to 'dominant' you can think of in the Champions League, I don't know who are.
_____________________________
I tried to groan, Help! Help! But the tone that came out was that of polite conversation. Empire Top 100 Albums Poll 2013: CLICK HERE
|