Spaldron
Posts: 10487
Joined: 6/10/2006 From: Chair
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: adambatman82 quote:
ORIGINAL: homersimpson_esq I've been very fortunate over the past three years to catch Sunrise, King of Kings, The Passion of Joan of Arc, La Roue, J'Accuse, Neighbors, and now The General, all on the big screen with live accompaniment. It's how they were meant to be, and it makes it electric. I saw PASSION in complete silence in Leeds cathedral. It was quite something. Continuing the pedantic streak (as per twitter), a couple of those films did actually have scores produced for them on initial release. Sunrise certainly did, and it's notable for being one of the first films with an actual "sound" track. Not only did it have music, but it also had sound effects too. All it lacked was dialogue. My point being, that to suggest that seeing them accompanied is "how they were meant to be" is actually a little off the mark, and would have been considered sacrilege by an "artist" like Murnau who would have wanted his work to have been seen exactly as he intended, and not with someone else's music playing over it. Why I love film - the opportunity for genuine debate. Slightly but does the dvd of Sunrise feature the original score Murnau intended? I'm only asking because I remember watching The General on dvd and the music really didn't fit, it sounded like it was done on a Casio keyboard in 1986 and didn't sound anything like your traditional silent score. Reminded me of when Queen redid Metropolis.
_____________________________
And I heard a voice in the midst of the four beasts And I looked and behold, a pale horse And his name that sat on him was Death And Hell followed with him.
|