Register  |   Log In  |  
Sign up to our weekly newsletter    
Follow us on   
Forum Home Register for Free! Log In Moderator Tickets FAQ Users Online

Another Earth

Logged in as: Guest
  Printable Version
All Forums >> [Film Forums] >> Film Reviews >> Another Earth Page: [1]
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
Another Earth - 16/12/2011 8:38:20 PM   
Dr Lenera


Posts: 4084
Joined: 19/10/2005
I can't find a review thread about this movie, except the one in Future Films, so I hope nobody minds me starting one and posting my review.

Rhoda Williams is a high school student fascinated by Astronomy who has been recently accepted to MIT [Massachusetts Institute Of Technology].    She celebrates with friends and drives home intoxicated. Listening to a story on the radio about an approaching planet that looks just like Earth, she looks out her car window up to the stars and inadvertently slams her car through a stopped car at an intersection, putting John Burroughs in a coma and killing his wife and son.  After serving her six year prison sentence, Rhoda becomes a school cleaner and visits John to apologise, but loses her nerve and instead poses as a maid offering a free day of cleaning.  Meanwhile people are fighting to get on to the space ship that will visit Earth 2 [as they call it] and there is a competition offering free tickets……………

Another Earth is a film that will probably frustrate a great many people.  Though certainly ‘science fiction’, it’s more of a human drama with metaphysical and philosophical elements, with the science fiction as a background for much of the film.  It’s also something of a puzzler which will probably make you scratch your head for quite a while.  The closest movie this year I can compare it to is the similarly polarizing Tree Of Life, though of course Another Earth is a very tiny budget movie by comparison.  There were moments where I got a little frustrated with the film, but overall, if you have patience and don’t expect lots of action, special effects etc., you may find it quite rewarding.  I came out of the cinema thinking intently about what I had seen, and, though I think the movie could have been better in some areas, I have a feeling that it will stay with me and will me even more rewarding on a second viewing.

Of course the idea of two people becoming close, one unaware the other did them a grevious wrong, is hardly a new concept; Bounce, Stuck and others have dealt with it, but this movie does it with a great deal of reality; you really believe the characters and their actions.  You know there is eventually going to be the scene where Rhoda tells all to John, but John’s reaction is totally believable.  I will say that much of this moves at a snail’s pace, and I wanted more of the film to be about the ‘Earth 2’ sub-plot, but never mind, I admire the writer/director Mike Cahill and his co-writer Brit Marling [who also stars] for ignoring expectations and having the guts to give us a very European-style human drama channelling the works of filmmakers like Krzysztof Kieslowski and Andrei Tarkovsky more than any American director.  The matter of Earth 2 might be more in the background, but it’s still there, often literally.  We spend much time with Rhoda outdoors, thinking, and the planet always looms in the background down at her, like God, watching from the Heavens, judging this human being who committed a dreadful act and is trying to atone for it.  Eventually we have the obligatory ‘contact’ scene, and I’ll be damned if it isn’t one of the creepiest scenes of the year.

Throughout, the movie has a dreamlike feel.  The camera is often following Rhoda right up behind her, handheld and jerking. At other times it’s looking down at her from above.  Scenes often employ disorientating editing. Despite it’s often intimate feel, Another Earth employs a wider range of cinema techniques than many other films I’ve seen this year and more experimentation.  Eventually the story does reach a kind of climax, and sorry to say we never actually get to see Earth 2, or should I say never think we do, because there are many possible interpretations to the film and yours is probably just as valid as mine.  In any case, the probable keeping of Earth 2 in our heads works best for the movie, because our minds can conjure up things in a way a film often just cannot match.  The tale seems to partially resolve itself it, bringing forward the theme of redemption and adding one of self-sacrifice, and then, we have a completely puzzling ending.  What does it mean?  How you interpret it probably depends on whether you prefer to go for the scientific or the philosophical.

Brit Marlin is simply sensational in the lead role; she seems to have a very fresh, naturalistic acting style, often letting just a subtle expression speak more far more than any heavy emoting, and I think she will be a big star in the future.  Co-star William Mapother seems a bit too creepy throughout.  A big plus in Another Earth is the score by the band Fall On Your Sword, ranging from traditional ‘classical’ type scoring to techno-y ambient sounds, with several particular instruments, such as organ, guitar and violin, seemingly used to emphasise certain situations or re-occurring elements.  There’s one really puzzling scene where John plays Rhoda really strange sounds with a violin bow and a buzz saw, and she seems to have images of a kind which I won’t describe but may be visions, or even flashbacks?  There are other things which didn’t really work for me.  A brief sex scene is just laughable, while I didn’t understand the role of the Indian co-worker, though it seems to have been important.  The grain of some shots jarred with the beauty of others, though it’s possible that could not have been avoided.   The more I think about this movie as I write this review though, the more I like it.  It’s affecting and even powerful in a curiously understated way, and I expect truly great things from Cahill in the future.



check out more of my reviews on
Post #: 1
RE: Another Earth - 21/12/2011 3:59:53 PM   


Posts: 1
Joined: 21/12/2011
I don't know.....
The...." really puzzling scene where John plays Rhoda really strange sounds with a violin bow and a buzz saw..."(actually it's a regular handsaw, NOT a buzz saw), that didn't work for you got some really great reviews elsewhere:

"..a heartbreaking solo with a bow and an old-fashioned handsaw becomes one of the most moving musical moments in memory.”
LA Times
"..the most resonant scene is the one…(with)…a musical saw. The eerily beautiful sounds cascade and twist though the air, sounding like the precise halfway point between the music of the spheres and a human sob.”
The Boston Globe

"In one of Mr. Mapother's surprising turns, he plays a soul-filling solo on a musical saw.”
Wall Street Journal

"The movie includes a couple of unforgettable scenes. One takes place in a college classroom, where John plays a saw whose eerie spiritual sound evokes a Gregorian chant.”
Bloomberg News

"…an eerie, unearthly and beautiful melody…”
MSN Movies

"…a keening piece for musical saw.”
Houston Chronicle

"A scene in which the professor coaxes almost human voices from a musical saw is stirring”
Memphis Commercial Appeal

"They…fall in love a bit hastily following a private concert in which John plays a piece on a musical saw for her. The melody he plays is eerily spot-on…”

"… a stunning piece of music…”

"One of the most interesting songs in the movie…”

"…a haunting melody…”
Montgomery News

Edit - no advertising personal sites, please. 

< Message edited by elab49 -- 21/12/2011 4:42:48 PM >

(in reply to Dr Lenera)
Post #: 2
RE: Another Earth - 16/5/2012 10:54:05 AM   
Vitamin F


Posts: 563
Joined: 6/10/2005
From: Norn Ireland, so it is

This would make quite a good companion piece to Take Shelter, both films loosely being character studies of troubled souls in the face of some supernatural event. This is the more satisfying experience, as I found Take Shelter to be lacking any point whatsoever come the final scene, but with this kind of story it's the journey that can be enjoyed, whilst waiting for that inevitable "is it or isn't it?" type of question to be answered by the finale.

As long as you don't give any thought to the scientific conundrums thrown up by the appearance of a duplicate Earth appearing in the sky, this is a pretty good drama about loss, redemption, second chances, none of which may be very original but at least it's handled in a subtle way and the melodrama is for the most part non-existant. A blessing.

The haunting closing scene, while executed well enough to be an extremely eerie conclusion, also throws up a lot more questions that the audience are left to debate for themselves, and once again logic flies out the window if you think about it too much.

So it's not perfect, there are certain elements that I didn't seem to get the relevance of (the old Indian, the saw gig, the closing shot) but if you want something non-Hollywood and ponderous (but not too ponderous) then give it a go.
Brit Marling (as lead and co-writer) is quite brilliant too. Never heard of her before this.

(in reply to Dr Lenera)
Post #: 3
Page:   [1]
All Forums >> [Film Forums] >> Film Reviews >> Another Earth Page: [1]
Jump to:

New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts

Movie News  |  Empire Blog  |  Movie Reviews  |  Future Films  |  Features  |  Video Interviews  |  Image Gallery  |  Competitions  |  Forum  |  Magazine  |  Resources
Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI