logboy
Posts: 332
Joined: 17/10/2005
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: UTB quote:
ORIGINAL: foz The cuts to The Isle don't ruin the film, but make the overall package a completely different one. To be honest, Ki-Duk's portrayal of a woman who cared about absolutely nothing is incredibly hard going for those (myself included) who own the uncut version. The cuts to the R2UK edition are enforced by UK law rather than the BBFC themselves, and go way beyond the unpleasantness inflicted on the fish, frog & snake in Spring, Summer etc (although that was also cut for the UK). Indeed, Kim seems to have it in for our aquatic chums, as 1 frog and several fish are tortured in The Isle, as well as a dog and a particularly upsetting scene featuring a caged bird. I can see what the director was (hahaha ahaha erm) angling for with these scenes to counter the beauty of the setting, but without the moral consequences shown in Spring, Summer..., it feels a bit unnecessary and detracts from the film as a whole due to these images being so strong as to be the only ones that the viewer takes from it when there are so many positives in there. The Isle uncut is an extremely good study of people finding emotion where they previously had none, but it takes you to some very dark places on the way. Well i doubt it's going to be a kid's film without the added animal dissection so i'll reserve judgement until i see it.. To be honest though, going by various websites and what they have said is cut, i'm not going to miss a terrible amount. And while i would usually hunt down the uncut version, since i got this version for a couple of quid, i'm not going out of my way and getting a region-free player just to see some extra animal gore. the HK disc is dirt cheap and uncut. since you have what i would term a 'multiregion taste' in that youve bought a film that could lead you into other films by the same director, from the same country or similar countries - then you need, in my opinion, a 'multiregion player' to get the most out of your interest. and to avoid film censorship. which always makes the film 'not as intended'.
|