Rinc
Posts: 12504
Joined: 2/10/2005 From: A park bench, with a newspaper quilt
|
30. Seinfeld (28) (1990-1998) I used to be so protective of Seinfeld. In the mid-90s the BBC and their idiotic scheduling screwed up any chance of it becoming incredibly popular in the UK (much like they have with Arrested Development this decade) and I was forced to listen to school then college friends telling me why Friends was a much better show. All of this forced me into a state of mind where I started claiming that Seinfeld was the greatest, darkest and funniest sitcom ever created. Of course it isn't. There are better comedies out there, but Seinfeld is still one of the best, not quite the greatest American comedy show of all time, but it's way up there. For those who've never seen the show it stars stand-up comedian Jerry Seinfeld as... stand-up comedian Jerry Seinfeld. That's nothing that unusual for American sitcoms, many stand-up stars play themselves, or versions of themselves in sit-coms, but I don't think any wrote themselves as unflatteringly as Seinfeld did. Show Jerry is vain, neurotic, petty, and mean-spirited. His circle of friends are just as bad. Neighbour Kramer is a free-loading kook, Elaine could have been the token normal character but she's just as unpleasant as the rest of the characters. The jewel in the crown however is George an overweight, balding, hateful, neurotic, dumb, mean, dishonest, insecure, workshy little ball of self-loathing, played without a hint of vanity by the wonderful Jason Alexander. Seinfeld is a rare American sitcom in that none of the lead characters are written to be sympathetic. They're our identification figures, so of course we end up on their side, even though the writing is constantly telling us what horrible people they are. Not many American sitcoms could have a character gleefully celebrating the death of his fiancee and still be one of the highest rated shows on television. Described within the series itself as 'a show about nothing', Seinfeld gets its laughs from placing the characters in mundane but absurd situations, getting entire episodes from misunderstandings over the ownership of a pen, a barking dog, a forgotten parking spot or a loaf of bread. Is Seinfeld without its flaws? Of course not. Like all other shows it had weak episodes, but for a show that lasted as long as it did, the hit-rate is astonishing, also, the fact that it never fell into easy sentiment is incredible. One of the few American shows that got the popularity within its own country that it deserved. A remarkable comedy. Rawlinson 29. Life On Mars (45) (2006-2007) "My name is Sam Tyler. I had an accident, and I woke up in 1973. Am I mad, in a coma, or back in time? Whatever's happened, it's like I've landed on a different planet. Now, maybe if I can work out the reason, I can get home…” "I'm Gene Hunt. Your DCI. And it's 1973. Nearly dinner time. I'm 'aving hoops.” Original, inventive, well-written with a multitude of cracking one liners, beautifully created characters (with an addition to the pantheon of TV gods) – who'd have thought it of recent UK drama? In a show that also turns the test card girl into something scarier than most J-Horror and perverts Trumpton along the way? Matthew Graham and Tony Jordan made all the right decisions – 2 perfect seasons, not too long, no filler – all part of the arc with clues to the outcome, following Sam's trip down the yellow brick road. And a perfect finale. One blinding smile and a shocking and brave decision from the writers. With a seemingly outlandish scenario they needed quality to keep it grounded. John Simm has proven himself as one of the best of his generation with roles in State of Play and as an almost definitive Raskelnikov in Crime and Punishment and his Sam Tyler is never less than compelling as the tech age cop kicked back to The Sweeney. Gene Hunt could easily have a caricature but the writing and Philip Glenister give him more depth than that. Still – he was "an overweight, over-the-hill, nicotine-stained, borderline-alcoholic homophobe with a superiority complex and an unhealthy obsession with male bonding? " – which isn't a bad thing! And it's clear how much they enjoy writing for him. Full credit should also be given to Annie Cartwright (Liz White), Chris Skelton(Marshall Lancaster) and Ray Carling(Dean Andrews). For the rest? I leave it to their own words. My favourite? Hunt: How do you think I spend my time here, Tyler? Tyler: Building a Death Star? elab49 The central idea is brilliance itself. How do you replicate the grim, boozy, smokey cop shows of the 70s, complete with misogyny and an utter lack of political correctness, without spoofing it? Why, simply throw in a bit of time-travelling sci-fi and have a 21st century copper travel back to the 70s in a cross between Quantum Leap and The Sweeney. Life on Mars works on so many different levels, which is why its two series are so endlessly watchable. Firstly, it works on the level of a straight up police drama of the 70s dealing not just with murders and armed robberies, but deep-rooted corruption, racism in the force and the birth of football violence, to name but a few. It works as a wry satire of those 70s dramas (but without sneering at them) while calling to mind so many other facets of 70s culture, such as Camberwick Green (which stands as one of the best episode openings ever). And it works as a mystery - what has happened to Sam Tyler? Is he dreaming or is he really back in time? Ultimately, that last one doesn't matter because the real joy is seeing 21st century boy John Simm butting heads with his 70s superior, Gene Hunt. Simm deserves all the praise he gets as Sam (as do the other characters of Annie, Chris and Ray), but the real reason we love Life on Mars is the monstrous Hunt. A swearing, violent, sexist, racist pig, who rarely lets the rules trouble him, he also sweats charisma and deep down, is the kind of copper we'd all want on our streets. Philip Glenister must have wanted to kiss his agent when he got the scripts for this, as every line that falls from his mouth is quotable ("He's as fake as a tranny's fanny!") and Glenister has an absolute ball with him. Gene Hunt may have moved onto the 1980s (and possibly beyond...), but Life on Mars is where he's at his best. matty_b 28. Supernatural (35) (2005- ) This show wasn't very good. Strange way to introduce an entry to the top 100 tv shows but it's true. Generic, constant movie of the week storylines that were watchable at best. Then something happened.... season 2. The show came back on a new network with a new attitude, it was suddenly cool, suddenly genuinally funny, thought provoking, dark. There were signs of it's potential as the first run drew to a close but all of a sudden it was sure of itself, and I was sure of it's quality as the viewer. Some of the storylines were still not exactly original but they had a 'Supernatural' twist on them and the dialogue was razor sharp. Jensen Ackles and Jared Paladeki also became the characters and both continue to give stellar perfromances. The mythology of the show had a direction too, if it was being made up as things went along then good on them, it still feels like it was all planned from the start. Also the writers aren't afraid to push the boundaries of what they can do, a murderous santa claus? An alcoholic suicidal teddy bear that blows out it's own stuffing with a gun? JUst some of the brilliantly bizarre scene's this show has produced. They've even sent the lead character to Hell! As season 4 got underway the show continued to get darker, playing with religious stories about a war between Heaven and Hell and even having the audacity of making the angel's (well a lot of them) and bad as the deamons from Hell, a bold move that helps make the show more complex, much darker, and much much better. And now as we enter the 5th (and ever more likely final season) the show continues to impress. A teen show that 'made scary sexy' (apparently) it may have been, now it's so much more. Joedini 27. ER (46) (1994-2009) Originally concieved as a film, it was decided by the powers that be that the idea was better suited to a tv show, and it went on to be one of the most successful in tv history, with 23 Emmy awards and 123 nominations Fifteen seasons, so many more tears, dramas and laughs as we watch the lives, loves, and some deaths, of the staff of Cook County General hospital in Chicago. Fast paced, genuine believable characters, real situations, from the mundane (flu, vomiting) to large disasters (plane, car and bus crashs, hell, a helicopter crashed in the ambulance bay) we're in amongst the action as the team fight to save the lives of strangers and friends/family alike. Starting with a cast of fairly unknowns (Anthony Edwards, best remembered before ER as Goose in Top Gun was probably the best known at the time), some who went on to big pretty big stars (George Clooney anyone?), we were thrown in at the deep end as we are introduced to Mark Greene, Doug Ross and Peter Benton, to name a few, as they teach medical students, deal with the workload of the hospital, as well as try to live their lives outside of work. Over the shows run we had shootings, drug addictions, love affairs, daring rescues and much more to keep us gripped and entertained throughout. The show hit its peak in between seasons two and eight, by which point most of the original cast had left, but carried on with new staff members taking the workload and bringing the drama through the sliding doors of the ER. benmharper 26. Scrubs (11) (2001- ) Scrubs is set in Sacred Heart Hospital and follows protagonist John ‘JD’ Dorian (Zach Braff) who in season one starts out as an intern - as the seasons progress, as does his medical career where he finally becomes an attending physician. It is not as serious as it sounds however; sure there are core elements that require reflection, most notably in the final five minutes of each episode where one learns most of their life lessons, but it is also a comedy. JD’s oddball humour is primarily shown through a number of daydream sequences similar to that of Family Guy’s departure clips. The supporting cast also contribute to the sometimes relentless comedy. Christopher Turk, JD’s best friend has an energy that is eternally funny, whether it is when he is annoying love Carla or his antics with JD, you’ll never get bored with this character. Eliot Reed and her neurosis can be a difficult character to like at first, but soon you will warm to her character. Perry Cox, starts off being one of the better characters in the show but soon descends into a constantly moaning person which becomes tired over the eight seasons. Similarly, the mysteriously names Janitor is a difficult character to like, he quickly becomes annoying as he persistently tortures JD – ‘it all started with a penny’ he sings in one episode – well fucking get over it! Bob Kelso, the chief of medicine in the hospital is the highlight of the show. What plays alongside the comedy is touching drama – the majority of episodes have JD’s voiceover (some episodes are done by other characters which is a refreshing change) and offers a chance for reflection and it cleverly offers a precise view on everyday life in a hospital setting. Certain episodes also end on a sombre note, this is a show that can be taken seriously and one that can you can have on the background – it finds the right mix and is altogether better for it. The writer’s strike inevitably affected the series, with the seventh and proposed final season cut short and an eighth season made. It has now been extended to a ninth season with Braff’s JD only making guest appearances. Sumintelligentguy 25. Arrested Development (18) (2003-2006) "Now the story of a wealthy family who lost everything, and the one son who had no choice but to keep them all together. It's Arrested Development." Arrested Development is proof perfect that America doesn’t just produce the best drama and science fiction - it also produces comedy of unparalleled calibre. In my opinion it isn’t just the best American sitcom of all time, it is also the finest comedy show ever made - anywhere. The fact that it ran for only 3 seasons is perhaps a blessing - there was never the time for the writers to drop the stratospherically high standard. The premise of the show is a simple ‘riches to rags’ one. Centred primarily around Michael Bluth (Jason Bateman) and his son George Michael Bluth (Michael Cera) as they return to help their family after the arrest of Bluth patriarch George Sr (played by the always-wonderful Jeffrey Tambor), the show follows the privileged Bluth’s as they struggle to maintain their materialistic and hedonistic lifestyles in the face of all manner of trials and tribulations (most of which are created through the self-centred actions of the family members themselves). What follows is a perfect mix of the absurd, subtle, farcical and even, occasionally, sweet and warm-hearted. Using the tried and tested foundation of the dysfunctional family, it takes the formula to comedic levels on a par with those of The Simpsons during it’s mid-nineties golden age. It’s shot in a mocumentary style that some may find takes time to get used to but helps keep some of the more outlandish stories believable, and it’s anchored throughout by Ron Howard’s wonderfully dry, knowing narration. Michael’s constant battles to prevent his avaricious and self-centred family from destroying themselves is the principal theme, but the richness of the characters and their interactions take the show far beyond. There is Michael’s older brother Gob (played by Will Arnett), a dim-witted and bombastic failed magician who constantly undermines Michael in a futile quest for affirmation and respect from his father. There is his narcissistic and lazy sister, Lindsay Funke (Portia de Rossi), and her analyst/therapist (or as he terms it, “analrapist”) husband Tobias (outstandingly portrayed by David Cross). Tobias’ habit of unwittingly uttering homosexual double-entendres (“I’m afraid I just blue myself”) is one of the recurring jokes throughout the show. Lindsay and Tobias’ daughter Maeby (Alia Shawkat) provides a romantic aspiration for George Michael, who struggles with the morality and frustration of harbouring feelings for his cousin. Michael’s overly mothered youngest sibling Buster (Tony Hale) is socially inept and childlike. Manipulating them all with Machiavellian glee is the mother, Lucille (Jessica Walter), who drinks like a fish and refuses to make eye contact with waiters. On paper, these characters seem an unlikely lot for a comedy show. The genius of Arrested Development lies in making such dysfunctional and flawed people not only extremely funny, but also likeable. It is impossible not to warm to the Bluths, which is achieved not just through the quality of the performances but also the exceptional writing. Arrested Development is incredibly dense, and demands repeated viewings to fully appreciate. Jokes both visual and spoken are almost constantly thrown at the viewer, though the show never becomes chaotic. The sheer dynamism of the performances and quality of writing defy an explanation in this blurb to do them justice, so all I can do is urge anyone who is yet to experience it to give it a go. Poor viewing figures may have led to a premature demise for Arrested Development, but genius can never be ignored which is possibly why rumours of a movie have followed ever since the show finished. Universal critical acclaim and award success for any TV show is rare; for an off-beat comedy show it is rarer still. Anyway, I’ll leave it to David Cross, in his infamous rant to Fox executives who turned up on set, to sum up what most AD fans feel: “I’ve got an idea for what you can do, why don’t you fucking fire your complete marketing team, alright? Get a new one in that knows how to market a show that’s won five motherfucking Emmys, Golden Globes, SAG awards, WGA awards, Producers Guild awards, Critics Top 10 List…you know, if you can fucking, if you can’t fucking market that kind of show and get better ratings then maybe the problem doesn’t lie here, maybe it lies with marketing. Goodnight.”. Oh Tobias - you blow hard! superdan 24. Fawlty Towers (22) (1975-1979) Still the best thing done by any Python post-Python (I mean creatively themselves – so GBH is excluded). Shortly after Python finished on TV, Cleese co-created a small comedy situated in a fictional hotel in Torquay. Only 12 episodes were filmed and, like Python itself, it is one of the few TV shows with a genuinely worldwide fanbase and, unfortunately for Cleese, it is the role more than any other that he has struggled to move on from. Married to the brisk Sybil (the sublime and brilliantly cast Prunella Scales), Basil Fawlty teeters constantly on the edge of frustrated hysteria – obsequious to classes above him, a dismissive snob to everyone else and terrified of falling foul of his wife. The hotel would be so much better without guests. Aided by the harassed and efficient maid Polly (Co-creator Connie Booth) and not so much aided by useless Spanish waiter Manuel (Andrew Sachs). The show combined slapstick, brilliant one-liners, more traditional humour based round misunderstanding (normally as a result of Manuel's comedy English), translated to excruciatingly embarrassing situations that always went one step further than you thought you could bear and a tremendously well-written war of attrition between husband and wife that took the observational elements of painful relationships to rarely matched comedy heights. Cleese on beating the car http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zl3mfaWCnWw The Germans http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgAi7DYHA94 elab49 23. Family Guy (10) (1999- ) Lois Griffin: [reading paper] Oh, this is wonderful! Look at this, Peter! [gesturing toward story of the renaming of James Wood High] Peter Griffin: [reading off headline] 200 die in train derailment? Oh, God, Lois, that is just morbidly obese. Sick, twisted and politically incorrect, this animated series features the adventures of the Griffin family. Fat, child-like, head of household Peter Griffin (voiced by creator Seth MacFarlane) screws things up while doting wife Lois (Alex Borstein) tries to keep things on an even keel. Peter and Lois have three kids - put-upon daughter Meg (Mila Kunis), dumb teenager Chris (Seth Green) and the youngest, Stewie (MacFarlane again)- a genius baby bent on killing his mother and destroying the world. Their talking dog, Brian, keeps baby Stewie (MacFarlane again) in check while sipping martinis and sorting through his own life issues. Family Guy shouldn't work at all. Even by the witless standards of modern television, it is breathtakingly derivative: does an animated series about the antics of a boorish, suburban yob with a saintly wife, a hopeless son, a clever daughter and a baby sound familiar at all? Even the house in Family Guy looks like it was built by the same architects who sketched the residence of The Simpsons. However, Family Guy does work, transcending its obvious influences with reliably crisp writing and glorious sight gags contained in the surreal flashbacks which punctuate the episodes. Extremely funny and sometimes shocking (for those of a nervous disposition), Family Guy has been saved from cancellation twice, due to its popularity, and has now even garnered its own spin-off in the shape of The Cleveland Show. nomimalone 22. Dexter (20) (2006- ) (Spoilers) With Dexter we start at the start – the title sequence is one of the best conceived I've ever seen on TV and gives us plenty of forewarning on what's to come. It's like those pics you used to get in Ask the Family – a tiny bit of an everyday object and you have to guess what it is. It runs through Dexter's normal morning routine – same as every other worker in America. Wake-up. Wash and dress. Have breakfast. Head out. But zeroes in on the detail, a delicious creepiness to slicing eggs like slicing eyes, using knives, pulling ties. A perfect introduction to the abnormal perception of the everyday world that will follow. Dexter is a serial killer. He's known since he was a kid. But unlike most serial killers, his foster dad decided to train him to protect him and to push him to use his dark desires for good – he's a serial killer who kills other serial killers. Ideally placed as a blood splatter specialist for the police, he can track and trace and enact justice when the courts can't or the police miss the real clues. He also tries to fit into the world around him – aware he doesn't feel in the same way others do, he has a strong relationship with his foster sister. And, initially, a safe one with an abused woman who is happy that he doesn't push her emotionally further than she wants to go – she thinks it is consideration, rather than a lack of perception on how things should go. But when that rather graphically changes, Dexter himself begins to change – trying to empathise with others or at least understanding how that works. That part does get a little Grey's Anatomy at times – start with a problem then lo and behold, find a killer who can solve it. But obviously better written and acted. Each series follows an overall serial killer arc – series 1, a killer who bloodlessly takes bodies apart and has a strange affinity for Dexter. Series 2 it is Dexter himself who is the target. Series 3 is a little odder with Dexter partly responsible for creating the monster he has to deal with. At times, extremely well-written its major draw is a superb and oddly nuanced (given the lack of emotional awareness of Dexter himself) central performance from Michael C Hall. Although sadly over, my personal favourite of his relationships was with Sergeant James Doakes – an angry, violent ex-army police officer. The only one who knows Dexter is off and, when he gets too close, Dexter plays him like a well-tuned violin and gets to have some of the most honest and open conversations of the series with him. Coming soon for season 4 with one of my favourite actors joining in the fun, even with dips Dexter is a recommend watch. elab49 21. Peep Show (30) (2003- ) The Mitchell and Webb look on the BBC has the eponymous stars act out different sketches, some hit nicely, though most miss sadly. Their channel 4 show Peep Show however towers above not only The Mitchell and Webb look, but most other British comedies. It tells of the lives of Mark Corrigan (David Mitchell), a middleclass credit salesman living with old university friend Jeremy Osbourne (Robert Webb). At first glance it is hard to see how this show would work – it’s shown through the eyes of each character (bar one or two scenes) and Mark and Jeremy’s characters are so different from each other. As we delve closer into each character however we start to see how their differences actually bring them closer together, making their dynamic work well which incidentally provides the best comedy. The comedy is of a high quality – cringe humour is pushed to the brink here, many times you will be hiding behind your hands wondering why these characters have put themselves in such situations. One fine example in an early episode see’s Mark leave an answer phone message to the Sophie, the woman he loves from work and is a genuine example of true comedy genius. The show also offers some cracking one liners, not only from the main cast, but from the support cast also, especially Super Hans. What makes this show comedy gold though is the sheer audacity of some of the predicaments we find our lead characters in. In one episode, Mark wonders if he is in love with his manager Johnson, he then buys gay porn only for the Johnson to come to his flat and find it. If you have not yet seen this show, you are missing out on British comedy at heights rarely reached. Sumintelligentguy
< Message edited by Rinc -- 25/9/2010 10:31:57 AM >
_____________________________
No spoilers please: Invisiotext: [ color=#F1F1F1 ]text[ /color ]
|