DAVID GILLESPIE
Posts: 2883
Joined: 27/2/2007 From: Glasgow
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Dr Lenera THE EXPENDABLES Barney Ross is the leader of a group of mercenaries who carry out jobs others fear. When a mysterious millionaire called Mr Church recruits Ross' group to take out an island dictator, Ross and Lee Christmas sneak onto the island and find the place in turmoil while the real villain turns out to be an ex-member of Ross' team. Befriending a local girl ,Ross and Christmas escape from the island but Ross wants to to back for the girl he didn't save........ The Expendables does pretty much what it says on the tin. You know it's going to be a throwback to the 80s action movie and for the most part it doesn't disappoint. Testosterone to the max as tough guys slaughter tons of extras and blow lots of shit up while throwing amusing banter around as they do it. When I say tough guys, I mean probably the greatest cast in action movie history, and Sylvestre Stallone deserves great credit for getting so many action stars together and pulling off what probably just seemed like a fan's wet dream. Perhaps surprisingly, they all work well together, with no visable clash of egoes. Despite being a tough shoot everyone seems like they had fun, and it really shows in the finished product. The plot......well, it's like a catalogue of old action cliches. Mercenaries recruited for an especially dangerous job, former buddies now on opposite sides, a man having a guilty consience and going back into danger, a climactic assault on an island fortress etc, it's all there, but the script does just about give you enough background about most of the characters so that you do care about them. Some will want a lot more, but this isn't that kind of movie. After a leisurely opening 20 or so minutes, it becomes an almost non-stop progression of fights, car chases and gunfire. It's all back to basics stuff-you won't see a tank falling out of a plane here, but it is mostly very convincing, with little [visable] use of CG. Highlights are Jet Li's violent but deliberately amusing brawl with Dolph Lundgren, Stallone's incredibly brutal fight with Steve Austin and Jason Statham's expert knife slashing. I could have done with more of Li's martial arts skills, but that was only a small flaw compared to.... The editing! Sad to say even Stallone now has seen fit to join the ranks of action directors who think that shooting a scene with very fast cutting and lots of closeups while shaking the camera about is where it's at. I do think this style worked for the Bourne movies, but it's just so tiresomely overused now. When I see an action sequence I want to see it, not be part of it ,and it seems a very lazy way of doing things because filmmakers don't really need to choreograph things properly. It was obvious that some of the fighting in The Expendables [as with Ninja Assassin] was actually very impressive, but I just couldn't really see much of it. More to the point, no 80s action film was shot like this [God I remember the days when Cobra was considered to be edited too fast!] so, unless it was to cover up the slowness of the older cast members, I don't see why Stallone decided to do it like this. I was also disappointed with the gore. Certainly not in quantity of course, with people being slashed, blown apart, you name it, it's all present and correct. No, I mean in quality. I kind of hoped they might have done this stuff the old way, with blood squibs and dummies, but no, it seems to be mostly CG gore, and as usual it doesn't look especially good. The dialogue is either absolutely dreadful or total genius, I haven't quite decided yet, but it works for the film. The much commented-on scene with Stallone, Bruce Willis and Arnold Schwarzenegger is wonderful and surprisingly subtle, considering they could have just made it a series of jokes-I just wish it had been longer. All the cast members give appropriate performances, in a way many of them are plaving some half-remembered version of themselves in the 80s, rather then particular roles, and that's just fine. Stallone graciously remains low key throughout and lets others like Dolph Lundgren [though he's not in it enough] dominate the scenes they are in. Of course the two women in the film simply exist to be beaten up and rescued! Brian Tyler's score just about backs up the onscreen carnage but is very run-of-the-mill. All in all this is certainly a good time at the pictures and will make any action film fan smile throughout. It does have it's problems though, and I don't think it's ever quite as good as it wants to me. Maybe the sequel will be though...... 7/10 Great review DL and I chose this yesterday. I agree with all your comments.
_____________________________
Cludge Judge * Cold Fish
|