Marwood
Posts: 2615
Joined: 1/10/2005 From: Only The Shadow knows
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Darth Marenghi quote:
ORIGINAL: Macavity There is an astounding amount of goodwill towards this film despite no indication of it being decent beyond the inclusion of Whedon. Whedon's enough to be honest - assuming for the moment he can crack the script. At his best, he certainly gets the Marvel ethos and given enough creative control will get a true Avengers movie onscreen. At the end of the day it could all go to pot but there's no reason not to be optimistic at the moment, as far as I can tell. Exactly, there's always a lot of negativity towards new genre films so it's nice to see some optimism about this one, I personally want it to succeed because of the ambition (and that I'm a fan of the characters of course) and that it opens the door to much bigger areas Marvel can explore with their future films - it's genuinely something that could move the sub-genre on in the same way that The Dark Knight had a huge impact and redefined what a superhero film could be. Reservations? Yeah sure, Iron Man 2 was a big stumble IMO (although I greatly enjoyed Iron Man and Incredible Hulk) with the larger Marvel U threads clumsily put into the film - one hopes that the future films won't have that problem because hopefully Marvel and the directors plan it better, all have admitted that IM2 was quite a rush job so even though Captain America's production history was a bit rocky and casting was all last minute hopefully it will come together. Thor and Captain America while both looking great from the trailer and screenshots respectively are risky and by no means slam dunks, if they fail then that will have a big effect on The Avengers - particularly if Chris' Hemsworth or Evans are terrible in the roles because we'll have to endure them again being terrible. However I'm hoping in both cases they knock it out of the park - Hemsworth seems to be rocking it as Thor in the trailers and I was a champion for Evans playing Cap for a long time when the film was in casting so I'm confident both will be great. I don't think either film will do Iron Man levels of business but just hope that they're comfortable hits that get people excited for a teamup. Whedon as a director I'm still unsure about but as others have said before if he has the right production team to smooth things out then there's no reason he can't make a good fist of this; he's in the same position as Raimi, Singer, Nolan and Favreau in terms of stepping up to something much bigger than previously directed so he's got every chance of being a success too. As a writer he's got the goods especially with superheroes so I've no worry that he and the producers will nail the script. My only proper concern is giving everyone their fair share of screentime; it's good that they have solo movies to introduce them but I still would like to see them develop as characters and with a large ensemble cast that's bloody difficult. While I really enjoy Bryan Singer's X-Men films they're very much about Wolverine, Magneto and Xavier while everyone else is pretty much background so my big ask of Whedon is that everyone gets their chance to shine in this film and it's not (for example) "STARRING RDJ, SLJ AND SCARJO....plus some muscle dudes and Ruffalo in a mo-cap suit".
_____________________________
Bilbo: What about the Ewoks? They were rubbish. Tim: Yeah but Jar Jar Binks makes the Ewoks look like f***ing Shaft!
|