quote:

ORIGINAL: Scruffybobby

quote:

ORIGINAL: Private Hudson

I think you guys are missing the point.

In Film Reviews it normally begins with an Empire Administrator posting a link to the official review. Why did they do this? Because you'd end up with 20 Blair Witch threads on the same forum.

So don't go all literal on the Film Review bit, because the review is actually Empires. The review is the catalyst for debate.

In case you don't know, anytime you bring up a new thread on a film anywhere else it gets moved or deleted or redirected to... Film Review!!!

I can see their point as they want to keep things a bit orderly.

Why not create an Amateur Film Review thread to keep all the aspiring Barry Normans happy?

No we're not missing the point at all. You just aren't making it very well.  I think what you're trying to say is that there should be a separate thread for discussion/debate. So why not just create a thread scalled "Can we have a separate discussion thread "or something along those lines

All you're doing now is coming at it  ass-backwards and making yourself look stupid by complaining about people using a thread for its clearly stated purpose instead of what you think it should be for.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Felix

I think you should stick to a subject you know well Hudson, like football...

How is your prediction of Utd's Red Empire crumbling coming along?

Whats that? They're Champions of England, Europe and the World?

quote:

ORIGINAL: jonson

To be fair I see Hudson's point and fair play to him for not reacting to the baiting most of you are dishing out.
I'd agree that I rarely read anyone's else's reviews, especially the really long ones that strike me as more "hey, look at me, I've got a GCSE in English" than anything remotely interesting.
That said, I can quite easily skip past these and read the ones that matter.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Stewie_Griffin

quote:

ORIGINAL: jonson

To be fair I see Hudson's point and fair play to him for not reacting to the baiting most of you are dishing out.

But he does make it so easy for us by being a blow-hard idiot.

quote:

ORIGINAL: richCie

he does have a point, reviews and discussion should be kept seperate, but yeh he made his point like a twat to begin with.