Rgirvan44
Posts: 18902
Joined: 10/3/2006 From: Punishment Park
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Rotary Ten quote:
ORIGINAL: Rgirvan44 quote:
ORIGINAL: Rotary Ten To repeat what's been said, it would be a gimmick, and quite a pointless one. If you want to explore the issues of a black Bond, I say that's fine, and interesting, Bond traditionally representing the British establishment, a black Bond being a potentially good post-colonial/early 21st Century look at the character, but I'd prefer that someone did a film like that outside the Bond series. People got annoyed and protested just because Daniel Craig has blond hair. I don't want to imagine the reaction to a black actor taking over the role. But how would it be a gimmick? If Bond is still a man who fights for Queen and country then what matter the colour of his skin? I think it would be a gimmick because I feel they'd be casting a black actor just for the sake of it. It comes down to the fact that even if they're not adapting a Bond novel, they're still adapting the character, and Bond is a white man. With good casting decisions they would still be good films, but it wouldn't be Fleming's Bond. I think you can change hair colour, accent, and tweak his background, but I think they have to keep some variant on what Fleming wrote for the character because a) there isn't anything wrong with him being white, and b) he's iconic. Now, I know you can argue that Fleming didn't write a female M, but I'd argue that M isn't anything like as identifiable a character as Bond is. But really, I just don't see any need whatsoever for Bond to be played by a black actor. I wouldn't have a problem with it, the films wouldn't be ruined, I just don't see the need to depart unnecessarily from Fleming's character. I would argue that one of the great things about Bond is that as a character he is pretty much a blank canvass. There only ever tend to be vauge details about his background (this is the film Bond I am talking about) which allows different interpetations. Any actor that can bring something to the table should be considered regardless of their background. I would agree if you were making a Bond set in the 1950s for the sake of realism but the movies are always set in the period when they were filmed.
_____________________________
It is a far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done; it is a far, far better rest that I go to, than I have ever known.
|