Mogwai
Posts: 671
Joined: 30/9/2005 From: Northern Ireland
|
Is it me or does anyone find that there seems to be a Clive Barker book in every charity shop they go to? I think I've seen Sacrament about five times, perhaps a) there are a lot of Barker fans where I live and they want everyone to read his books or b) there are no fans. All my Clive Barker books are from charity shops (I don’t have all his books) apart from Imajica, which was the first Barker novel I read. Actually, it was Books of Blood. I really wish they would publish his novels again, on a purely aesthetic level because a lot of them look really tatty and corny looking. The designs are naff, even Abarat with Barker's own paintings is let down by the badly designed cover. Anyway, I bought The Hellbound Heart from Barnados last week. If anyone has seen Hellraiser, the film based on the novella, then you know what to expect here. It’s the same apart from a couple of instances. Surprisingly, this is one of those less-than-frequent times when a film is better than its source material. It seems that Barker, when he wrote and directed Hellraiser, took away all the things that made the novella, well, naff. It all comes across as a bit trite, and not particularly scary (unlike the film). The depiction of the Cenobites is mostly laughable; they come across as shockingly civil and friendly. In the film, and I don’t like comparing a book and a film but in this instance it is hard not to, they are relentless, unremitting, inhuman. In the book they’re more like “well tally ho, we’ll just put some hooks into you eh boyo!”. Also, Pinhead isn’t in it. Well, he is but he isn’t named and is very inconsequential. He does have the two classic lines “…tear your soul apart” and “no tears please it’s a waste of good suffering”. Of course it sounds much better in the film; Pinhead is quite a charismatic figure, apart from the whole tearing you apart for pleasure/pain and the increasingly daft sequels that rendered him a shell of his former self. Actually, is it even him who says those lines in the book? I can’t even remember it now. It doesn’t have the “Jesus wept” line which is pitch-perfect in the film. Instead Frank says “fucking bitch” which doesn’t quite have the same ring to it. Anyway, it wasn’t bad and perhaps I would have enjoyed more if I hadn’t watched the film first. I don’t know. It wasn’t very good, probably the worst by Barker.
_____________________________
http://damnedconjuror.wordpress.com/ - My Blog I was cut from her belly With a stanley knife My daddy did a jig With the drunk midwife
|