Spectre
Posts: 1512
Joined: 30/9/2005 From: Tokyo, Japan
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: evil bill By the way folks,i was meant to see Planet Terror at are local mulit plex but it's been dropped from the listing's I wondered why you hadn't posted your review yet. That's a real shame, because I think it's much better than Tarantino's self-indulgent Death Proof. No doubt it will only be showing near me for about a week, so I made the effort to go and see it today on the big screen before it disappears completely. The plot revolves around the characters of El Wray and Cherry Darling, played by Freddy Rodriguez and Rose McGowan respectively, and sees them leading a group of survivors against an army of mutants. Needless to say, it's basic but provides a decent enough back drop for copious amounts of gore, of which exploding heads and severed limbs are just the start! Rodriguez and McGowan do well in their roles and are complemented by a supporting cast including Michael Biehn (himself worth seeing the film for), Tom Savini, Marley Shelton, Josh Brolin and more, all of whom embrace the spirit of the film well. It's also very funny, not just in terms of the violence, which is frequently both disgusting and hilarious, but also with regards to the dialogue. Considering that between Tarantino and Rodriguez, the former is widely acknowledged (not necessarily correctly) as the better writer, Death Proof is certainly inferior in terms of its script. Whilst Tarantino gets carried away with his trademark dialogue which soon becomes tedious, Rodriguez script is tighter, funnier and ultimately more in keeping with the tongue in cheek Grindhouse spirit, with some extremely quotable dialogue and one-liners. Furthermore, Rodriguez's score also helps maintain the aura of low budget 70s cinema, by way of its similarities with John Carpenter's synth scores. Needless to say, the film's not perfect. For a start it's too long and Tarantino's cameo is awful. Also whilst Rodriguez has crafted a better tribute to 70s exploitation cinema than Tarantino, ultimately I feel that the Grindhouse experiment has been a failure. Still, the main strength of Planet Terror, is that despite the failure of the Grindhouse project as a whole, it remains an extremely watchable and entertaining film... provided your not too squeamish and can appreciate a bit of tongue in cheek humour .
< Message edited by Spectre -- 12/11/2007 7:42:40 PM >
|