The Raid (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Film Forums] >> Film Reviews



Message


Empire Admin -> The Raid (27/4/2012 11:55:00 AM)

Post your comments on this article




TomBowler -> Truer words were never spoke (27/4/2012 11:55:00 AM)

5 Stars is exactly right. Saw this with a friend of mine. Both he and I are huge action fans and we were gasping, swearing and air-punching constantly. No eep-ing though. We don't eep.




talpacino -> RE: Truer words were never spoke (27/4/2012 12:53:27 PM)

Can't wait to see this again. Good to see the 5 stars. Great film.




Spaldron -> RE: Truer words were never spoke (27/4/2012 2:58:10 PM)

Awesome film, one of the finest Asian actioners ever filmed with some of the best martial arts ever committed to film.

5/5




retranimator -> STUNNING!!!! (10/5/2012 1:29:48 PM)

NEVER HAVE I TRULY WANTED TO GO SEE A FILM AGAIN DIRECTLY AFTER JUST SEEING IT.
THIS FILM DOSE NOT STOP AND IS JAW DROPPING FROM START TO FINISH.
EVEN IF YOUR NOT AT ALL A FAN OF NON ENGLISH SPEAKING FILMS, CHECK THIS OUT AS IT IT HAS VERY LITTLE DIALOGUE AS THE REST IS PURE ACTION!




hellsfoxes -> ima spoil the party (14/5/2012 3:02:22 AM)

yes there were a hell of a lot of fantastic moments and real action is beautiful to behold.

however this is not a great film. and as an action film i had a lot of probs.

SPOILERS

for a start there is no satisfying conclusion with the big bad. his right hand man, yes that fight was incredible if a little 'i wait here while you fight then il jump in', but the whole thing with the older corrupt cop... meh. he just wasn't compelling enough for the ending to revolve around and made the journey less interesting.

theres a lot of sloppy plot holes/plotting that really ruined the tension for me. like how the snipers next door were this huge deal and then they completely forget about them by the end. or how that intense scene where they were hiding from behind the wall is followed by the main guy walking uncharacteristically stupidly into the same group IMMEDIATELY AFTER.

i love dumb action movies and never thought i wud b missing the character development but i kept wondering how much time at the beginning would have made the whole thing better.. 5 minutes? 10? films like die hard/hard boiled/the killer have spoiled us for forever proving that hardcore action need not be a completely superficial affair. the raid is one note and whatever note that is (ooh ahh that was crazy), the lack of variation ends up watering down the individual pieces.




hellsfoxes -> delete post please (14/5/2012 3:10:31 AM)

delete post please




clownfoot -> RE: d (14/5/2012 1:29:01 PM)

Very excited. This may be the film that gets me to the cinema for the first time in over a year...




darkhart -> 5 stars.. seriously? (14/5/2012 7:53:17 PM)

Having just watched the trailer it looked liked a bunch of korean movie students who can't act or fight convincingly!




Shifty Bench -> RE: Truer words were never spoke (15/5/2012 1:06:17 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron

Awesome film, one of the finest Asian actioners ever filmed with some of the best martial arts ever committed to film.

5/5


Directed by a Welshman. I love that fact [:D]

Saw the trailer for this before Safe today and I can't wait to see it!




Happy Shrapnel -> RE: Truer words were never spoke (15/5/2012 9:00:32 AM)

Can't wait to see this, just hope it lives up to the hype !
Like the dig about Hollywood using shaky camera shots in fight scenes now, sick and tired of it myself !




Cameron1975Williams -> From the clip this looks immature and tiresome. (15/5/2012 12:58:01 PM)

I was bored by this minute long clip, and I hear the movie is pretty much like this from beginning to end. To put this in the same league as Die Hard is ludicrous. Empire is not often wrong, but this looks like one of those cases. Superman Returns, The Star Wars Prequels and Indian Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull are other cases. Empire, prepare to eat SMEG.




Shifty Bench -> RE: From the clip this looks immature and tiresome. (15/5/2012 1:50:30 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Cameron1975Williams

I was bored by this minute long clip, and I hear the movie is pretty much like this from beginning to end. To put this in the same league as Die Hard is ludicrous.



What they mean is, it's an action film that gives the genre a much needed shot in the arm. That is what Die Hard did and that is apparently what The Raid does too. I have heard many good reviews of the film from non-critics who have seen it and Empire are not the only only critics who like the film, so unless almost everyone who has seen it are wrong, the film is something special. Of course, that doesn't mean you are going to like it but apparently you have already made your mind up about it[:)]




OPEN YOUR EYES -> RE: From the clip this looks immature and tiresome. (15/5/2012 1:57:48 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Shifty Bench


quote:

ORIGINAL: Cameron1975Williams

I was bored by this minute long clip, and I hear the movie is pretty much like this from beginning to end. To put this in the same league as Die Hard is ludicrous.



What they mean is, it's an action film that gives the genre a much needed shot in the arm. That is what Die Hard did and that is apparently what The Raid does too. I have heard many good reviews of the film from non-critics who have seen it and Empire are not the only only critics who like the film, so unless almost everyone who has seen it are wrong, the film is something special. Of course, that doesn't mean you are going to like it but apparently you have already made your mind up about it[:)]


I can see where Cameron1975Williams is coming from though.Over long fight scenes can become somewhat repetitive.
But from early showings it seems to have a good enough plot to carry it along.

Personally speaking it looks like a blast.[:D]




horribleives -> RE: From the clip this looks immature and tiresome. (15/5/2012 3:18:05 PM)

I'm not one to dismiss something I haven't seen but from seeing the trailer and reading about it I'm fairly certain I'd get bored after about half an hour, like I did with virtually all of John Woo's early films and every martial arts flick I've ever attempted to watch.
But hey, you never know...




Shifty Bench -> RE: From the clip this looks immature and tiresome. (15/5/2012 10:10:19 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: OPEN YOUR EYES


quote:

ORIGINAL: Shifty Bench


quote:

ORIGINAL: Cameron1975Williams

I was bored by this minute long clip, and I hear the movie is pretty much like this from beginning to end. To put this in the same league as Die Hard is ludicrous.



What they mean is, it's an action film that gives the genre a much needed shot in the arm. That is what Die Hard did and that is apparently what The Raid does too. I have heard many good reviews of the film from non-critics who have seen it and Empire are not the only only critics who like the film, so unless almost everyone who has seen it are wrong, the film is something special. Of course, that doesn't mean you are going to like it but apparently you have already made your mind up about it[:)]


I can see where Cameron1975Williams is coming from though.Over long fight scenes can become somewhat repetitive.
But from early showings it seems to have a good enough plot to carry it along.

Personally speaking it looks like a blast.[:D]


I can see where he's coming from too but why attack* Empire about it when it's not just them that are highly praising the film? I'm seeing the film next week and I may well get bored of the repetitiveness too but at least I would have seen the film to make that judgement. And I wouldn't tell Empire to 'eat smeg' because they were 'wrong'. In fact, if he is bored by the clip he saw then maybe it's just not the film for him to begin with [:)]

*ok, 'attack' is a bit strong a word but it's the only one I could think of [:D]




sanchia -> RE: From the clip this looks immature and tiresome. (15/5/2012 10:28:27 PM)

How can you make a decision on whether a film is in the same league as Die Hard not, or how ludicrous the claim is, from a minute long clip? Personally from the trailers etc. it does not seem a film for me but there is the possibility it may turn out to be a decent film.




Spaldron -> RE: Superb film (16/5/2012 12:39:45 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Cameron1975Williams

I was bored by this minute long clip, and I hear the movie is pretty much like this from beginning to end. To put this in the same league as Die Hard is ludicrous. Empire is not often wrong, but this looks like one of those cases. Superman Returns, The Star Wars Prequels and Indian Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull are other cases. Empire, prepare to eat SMEG.


Judging a film before you've even seen it?

DRINK!



On a similar note I have seen it and its fucking amazing. [:)]




Wilemina -> Excellent Film (16/5/2012 9:09:45 AM)

I really enjoyed this film. I was pleasantly surprised when Cineworld previewed it in my small town cineplex. What I really liked was the close quarters camera work. Gave a real claustrophobic sense of perspective in the corridors.
Fingers crossed for loads of behind the scenes features on the home video release.




jmebaby25 -> RE: Excellent Film (16/5/2012 9:40:11 AM)

I guess I'll go and see this because the reviews have been great. What puts me off is the awful trailer with the large text saying:

"The greatest action movie ever!"

It makes me think of a cheap and nasty fast food store that has to describe their own food as "fresh" or "quality meat".




Whistler -> (16/5/2012 12:17:59 PM)

It's definitely one of the best action movies of recent times. The fight scenes are immense. Brutal, stylish and relentless, and all of them are incredibly well choreographed. And the best part? You can actually see what's happening! Other directors take note (*ahem* Gary Ross) - this is how you shoot fight scenes.




MuckyMuckMan -> RE: (16/5/2012 4:10:35 PM)

I saw the impressive The Raid at the Bradford International Film Festival about a month ago and oh boy did it not disappoint. From start to finish the film was unrelenting brutal chop socky action that will satiate the appetite of any action movie fan.
Yes ok the storyline wasn't the most original and the character development was near on non-existent but I don't think that was the point of the film. The film was, for me, a showcase for the most amazing martial artists to show their prowess in the art. Which leads me onto the action, needless to say it was so brutal and bone crunching in places that every now and then the audience would all wince and go oooooooooo!!!! simultaneously (especially with one particular takedown involving a door). Particular standouts on the action front have to go to the lead actor Iko Uwais who plays Rama and Yayan Ruhian who plays Mad Dog (the name explains it all). Truely, this is a must see for any action movie fan.

9/10





bernardshakey -> Does not disappoint. (17/5/2012 1:28:55 AM)

I heard so many good things about this from US websites I thought it must be all hype but it doesn't disappoint. Once it gets going it is totally relentless and you just wonder how a human being is capable of doing these things. Don't think I've ever heard an audience react to a film so vocally, they were feeling every punch. Highly recommended.




Emyr Thy King -> RE: The Raid (17/5/2012 2:27:41 PM)

Looks like Hirwaun is the conveyor belt of directors.




Darth Marenghi -> RE: The Raid (17/5/2012 11:24:27 PM)

Saw this today at a preview with a director Q & A post-screening. The film's an absolutely phenomenal piece of action film-making with some utterly insane but thrilling moments and as many blistering fight sequences as you could want. The plotting and characterisation is noticeably thinner than the action classics that Evans clearly grew up and loved like the rest of us, but this is more than compensated for by the charismatic Iwais and the inventive, brutal choreography. Really looking forward to seeing it again in the near future.




waqas5050 -> For once, the film matches and exceeds the hype! (18/5/2012 10:40:49 AM)

Lean, mean thrill machine and with not once ounce of fat! Iko Uwais is the newest international action star and with this he has booked his place in The Expendables 3 (if Stallone has any sense)! Finally a martial arts action epic where the story, acting and directing matches the numerous inventive fights on screen. See it to believe it and when you have caught your breath, see it again!




TheMightyBlackout -> RE: The Raid (18/5/2012 9:21:32 PM)

I would dearly, dearly like to know how many gunshots are in this film. It's certainly in four figures, and quite possibly in five. No, seriously. The first half of this movie sees a shell-count (and body-count) unlike anything I've witnessed in years. The second half focuses more on hand-to-hand martial arts, with more shouting and grunting than actual dialogue.
But all in all, it adds up to a spectacular ride, with genuine tension throughout.




danielthompson99 -> Believe the hype (19/5/2012 12:08:32 AM)

This is an awesome action movie. It is certainly the best "kung-fu" movie I've seen, and I want to see it again, now please!
The tension builds, you can feel the pressure and the awesome soundtrack helps build on the mood. Then all hell breaks loose. The action is ridiculous, the camera work is sensational, the editing is great too.
Top draw, could not recommend for a boys movie anything higher. If any girls like this, marry them.




Blyman -> Exhaustingly brilliant (19/5/2012 12:23:22 AM)

The Raid plus 5 lads, Curzon Soho (excellent cinema), beers and a Chinese equals unbeatable night. The audience clapped mid film after 'that' Mad Dog fight scene, says it all really.




imcalledadrian -> Phenomenal (19/5/2012 3:15:33 AM)

Breathtaking film with wonderfully imaginative fight scenes which earn their cheers...I caught myself several times watching it with a huge grin on my face.




Page: [1] 2 3 4   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
0.0625