RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (Full Version)

All Forums >> [On Another Note...] >> Small Screen



Message


theoriginalcynic -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (25/11/2011 1:26:13 PM)

Lets hope this one err ...actually has some jokes in it. 




Spaldron -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (25/11/2011 6:18:58 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: jcthefirst

quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron


Back to Earth was ace!



What is this I dont even.

I absolutely hated Back to Earth. A laugh vacuum.



It was brilliant and it had some genuinely funny moments (certainly a lot funnier than the previous two or three seasons) but I think the point of BTE was to be a bit more than just funny. The point was to kill of the characters and give the show a proper send off, which makes these new eps all the more confusing. Tbh Dwarf was never really that funny since Rob Grant left so seeing as he's not involved in this I'm going to hold my breath.




jcthefirst -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (25/11/2011 10:40:18 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron


quote:

ORIGINAL: jcthefirst

quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron


Back to Earth was ace!



What is this I dont even.

I absolutely hated Back to Earth. A laugh vacuum.



It was brilliant and it had some genuinely funny moments (certainly a lot funnier than the previous two or three seasons) but I think the point of BTE was to be a bit more than just funny. The point was to kill of the characters and give the show a proper send off, which makes these new eps all the more confusing. Tbh Dwarf was never really that funny since Rob Grant left so seeing as he's not involved in this I'm going to hold my breath.


But...they went to Coronation Street. It was awful.




Hood_Man -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (25/11/2011 10:48:17 PM)

I found it about as funny as a prostate examination.

Or how I imagine a prostate exam would be like.

If this guy was the doctor.


[image]http://filmoria.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/The-Wolverine.jpg[/image]




Spaldron -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (26/11/2011 1:38:43 AM)

The bit in Corrie wasn't great but it least it showed Craig Charles could take the piss out of himself. Like "ok yeah, this is where my career has ended up". [:D] And anyway's why does everyone always focus on that one bit of the ep?




NinjaShortbread212 -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (26/11/2011 2:55:29 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron

It was brilliant and it had some genuinely funny moments (certainly a lot funnier than the previous two or three seasons) but I think the point of BTE was to be a bit more than just funny. The point was to kill of the characters and give the show a proper send off, which makes these new eps all the more confusing. Tbh Dwarf was never really that funny since Rob Grant left so seeing as he's not involved in this I'm going to hold my breath.



That's a very good point and it's easy to look back in hindsight I guess also. Still, the thought of having it back on the air again fills me with wonderment! [:)]




Shifty Bench -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (26/11/2011 5:56:01 PM)

Back To Earth was pretty poor. Not very funny either but I hope this new series is better. Love me some (good) Red Dwarf.




jcthefirst -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (26/11/2011 7:49:56 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron

The bit in Corrie wasn't great but it least it showed Craig Charles could take the piss out of himself. Like "ok yeah, this is where my career has ended up". [:D] And anyway's why does everyone always focus on that one bit of the ep?



Because it's the absolute nadir of a set of awful episodes.

And if it was trying for comedy drama, I feel that series 7, maligned as it is, was better in that respect. Take Ouroborus for example, that had genuiine pathos and laughs. Back to Earth had crowbarred in Blade Runner references and attempts at meta humour that feel horribly flat.




Vadersville -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (26/11/2011 7:58:07 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron

Tbh Dwarf was never really that funny since Rob Grant left so seeing as he's not involved in this I'm going to hold my breath.



Sadly, I do think Grant was probably the more talented of the two and after he left we had only a fraction of what used to make Red Dwarf great left. Series 7 was, for the most part, dire and while I enjoyed parts of series 8, most notably the return of focus on the best friend / arch enemy relationship of Lister and Rimmer, I think it was a mistake to bring back the entire crew and the ending was crap.




jobloffski -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (27/11/2011 8:54:59 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Vadersville

quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron

Tbh Dwarf was never really that funny since Rob Grant left so seeing as he's not involved in this I'm going to hold my breath.



Sadly, I do think Grant was probably the more talented of the two and after he left we had only a fraction of what used to make Red Dwarf great left. Series 7 was, for the most part, dire and while I enjoyed parts of series 8, most notably the return of focus on the best friend / arch enemy relationship of Lister and Rimmer, I think it was a mistake to bring back the entire crew and the ending was crap.



Yes, bringing back the crew fucked it up because it destroyed the basis of the comedy, and just as crucially meant there were too many characters to write for. Small core cast repeatedly encountering new situations is the formula to follow, to allow focus on the main character relationships and how they antagonise each other in relation to the fixes they get into. The latter point is the formula for ALL classic sitcoms.

I'm probably not the only person to make the observations I did earlier in the thread, but it is nicely coincidental that almost EVERYTHING I critiqued as being why BTE didn't work as well as older Dwarf series' has been addressed by the new plan, most notably the return to less 'cinematic' shot composition and studio based live audience shooting (which formerly allowed even the lamer gags, and there WERE many groansome lines, to benefit the timing of delivery of lines according to setting up a live audience to laugh, and the instant comic energy provided to performers by the very act of playing to a crowd that is giviing them instant feedback and can be 'played' to increase the level of reaction over the course of a scene towards the big payoff).




S. C. Lee -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (4/12/2011 2:04:50 PM)

So, what's the deal with series nine? I've just written on my blog that the co-creator said, he wouldn't wanna make a series nine but he'd make a series ten (now in production.) I know they spoke about the fictional series nine in Back to Earth.  Will he go back and make it? Or ignore it? 




Shifty Bench -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (5/12/2011 11:44:48 AM)

I think Back To Earth will be counted as series 9 to avoid confusion. 




Shifty Bench -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (7/12/2011 3:59:29 PM)

New video of Cat and Kryten make-up tests-  http://www.sfx.co.uk/2011/12/07/red-dwarf-x-the-cast-get-ready-for-action/




Darth Marenghi -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (17/4/2012 6:12:35 PM)

Sad to hear that Peter Wragg, visual effects designer of Series I-VI has passed away at the age of 65. [&:]




Sotto Voce -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (17/4/2012 7:01:58 PM)

I've just caught up with the news. I am pleased. Didn't hate Back to Earth nearly as much as some, but hopefully it'll be back on form, and there's some commentary to that effect from studio audience members on the website.

BTW they're calling it Red Dwarf X on the website. Surely all that stuff about other series in Back to Earth is meaningless because it was all a false reality.[&:]




Shifty Bench -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (17/4/2012 7:06:36 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Sotto Voce

BTW they're calling it Red Dwarf X on the website. Surely all that stuff about other series in Back to Earth is meaningless because it was all a false reality.[&:]



It has been said you will discover why it is called series ten when the show airs, so it may not even be the same reason mentioned in Back to Earth.

I just count Back to Earth as series 9......




clownfoot -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (17/4/2012 7:16:07 PM)

I had no idea another series was being made. Please our wonderful monkey overlords, make this as brilliant as series 4 and 5 (studio audience instead of canned laughter is obviously a step in the right direction).




Shifty Bench -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (17/4/2012 7:24:58 PM)

Technically, they never used cann......oh, never mind [:D]

Anyway, I agree, having a live audience is certainly the right step to take. They tend to get too full of themselves when they don't have restrictions. I'm actually amazed that they got them all back. I'd really have thought Chris Barrie would have washed his hands of it again after the reaction to Back To Earth. Good on them all, though. I just hope this new series is actually funny. While I enjoyed Back to Earth, it was never laugh out loud hilarious.




Sotto Voce -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (17/4/2012 8:16:30 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Shifty Bench


quote:

ORIGINAL: Sotto Voce

BTW they're calling it Red Dwarf X on the website. Surely all that stuff about other series in Back to Earth is meaningless because it was all a false reality.[&:]



It has been said you will discover why it is called series ten when the show airs, so it may not even be the same reason mentioned in Back to Earth.

I just count Back to Earth as series 9......



Yeah, I just assumed that was the logic they're using. What I heard was that over the series you find out what happened after series 8, instead of there being a big explanation at the start. I don't think there's supposed to be some sort of 'missing' series 9.




KnightofZyryab -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (17/4/2012 9:51:03 PM)

Really looking forward to this - I was pretty disappointed with Back to Earth although having watched it again, it's not that bad, just not particularly funny. It didn't really feel like a series at the time because of how short it was, so this feels like the real return to the formula which worked so well in the earlier series. Red Dwarf was often as much about the great comic timing as it was the gags and that's what made the original series so great, because the actors were constantly timing their delivery in front of the audience.




Sotto Voce -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (18/4/2012 1:00:48 PM)

More encouraging news- models will be used instead of CG for Red Dwarf and presumably any other ships. I always loved he model shots in the early series. So much more effective than second-rate CG. I hope the ship is back to its original appearance as well. Didn't like the elongated version in series 8. From the website;

For Series X, however, the decision has been made to take the visual effects back towards their roots and so, as part of the final week of pickup shooting at Shepperton Studios, a special area has been given over to the second unit, in order that they can shoot space-bound sequences featuring actual, tangible ship miniatures. Other visual effects methods will of course be used in the series as and when appropriate but the ships themselves will be models.
The new model shooting unit is being headed up by Peter Talbot, an experienced director of photography with a particularly impressive CV when it comes to miniature work in both movies and television. As well as working on iconic franchises such as Batman, Iron Man and James Bond, he also shot the miniatures for Duncan Jones' Moon, a film not entirely dissimilar to Red Dwarf in its look and feel.
I think Red Dwarf is really back this time.[sm=51.gif][sm=18.gif][sm=51.gif]




Spaldron -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (18/4/2012 3:57:08 PM)

Visual effects aside I just hope this is nothing like series 7 and 8, both awful. The problem is the show hasn't really been any good since Rob Grant left so I'm going to remain sceptical for now.




Wedge -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (26/4/2012 10:51:53 AM)

The first photo from Red Dwarf X has been posted on Facebook

[image]http://a4.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc7/295024_227220747383923_136867133085952_348802_1115368771_n.jpg[/image]




jcthefirst -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (26/4/2012 12:11:59 PM)

Much as I reckon this won't be great, it's still good seeing them again.




darthbane -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (26/4/2012 1:10:18 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron

Visual effects aside I just hope this is nothing like series 7 and 8, both awful. The problem is the show hasn't really been any good since Rob Grant left so I'm going to remain sceptical for now.


I agree, 7 was pretty bad. The writing seem to concentrate mainly on grand, clever sci fi ideas, most of which were good, but they didn't lend themselves well to comedy.

Tikka to ride - The crew are involved in the Kennedy assassination
Ouroboros - Lister is his own father
Epideme - Sparing with the virus within Lister
Nanarchy - Red Dwarf was never stolen and has been amongst them all the time.

These are all great ideas and make for good episodes, but apart from a few gags, they're not really funny. The rest of the episodes were poor.
I did think that series 8 was a huge improvement, it wasn't without its problems, such as the ending and to many characters. However I welcomed the return of the two guys/one room situation that had been missing for a long while




Sotto Voce -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (6/5/2012 1:53:16 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: darthbane


quote:

ORIGINAL: Spaldron

Visual effects aside I just hope this is nothing like series 7 and 8, both awful. The problem is the show hasn't really been any good since Rob Grant left so I'm going to remain sceptical for now.


I agree, 7 was pretty bad. The writing seem to concentrate mainly on grand, clever sci fi ideas, most of which were good, but they didn't lend themselves well to comedy.

Tikka to ride - The crew are involved in the Kennedy assassination
Ouroboros - Lister is his own father
Epideme - Sparing with the virus within Lister
Nanarchy - Red Dwarf was never stolen and has been amongst them all the time.

These are all great ideas and make for good episodes, but apart from a few gags, they're not really funny. The rest of the episodes were poor.
I did think that series 8 was a huge improvement, it wasn't without its problems, such as the ending and to many characters. However I welcomed the return of the two guys/one room situation that had been missing for a long while


I'm the other way around. Liked 7, didn't like 8.

When you think about it, this will be the first time since series 5 its been back to the original formula in many respects (though without Rob Grant), so I am in cautiously optimistic mode. Even if its not back to the glory days, I think it will probably be better than the last couple of entries.

Howard Goodall back doing the music, I notice.




Shifty Bench -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (6/5/2012 2:04:59 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Sotto Voce
Howard Goodall back doing the music, I notice.



Hopefully they'll actually use his stuff this time.




Shifty Bench -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (20/7/2012 11:35:10 PM)

Trailer for Red Dwarf X- click

Looks a bit 'meh' but the Cat has a line that reminds me of classic, actually good, Red Dwarf.




Sotto Voce -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (21/7/2012 3:52:00 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Shifty Bench

Trailer for Red Dwarf X- click

Looks a bit 'meh' but the Cat has a line that reminds me of classic, actually good, Red Dwarf.



Really not enough there to make a judgement, but here's hopping. (That's a Red Dwarf reference, not a typing error.)




jcthefirst -> RE: Red Dwarf Appreciation Thread (21/7/2012 4:52:29 PM)

It made me laugh twice, which is more than Back to Eath did.

[:D]




Page: <<   < prev  5 6 [7] 8 9   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
6.298828E-02