The Battleship Potemkin (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Film Forums] >> Film Reviews



Message


Empire Admin -> The Battleship Potemkin (3/4/2008 5:56:56 PM)

Post your comments on this article




jamdodge1 -> Solid but overrated (3/4/2008 5:56:56 PM)

Eisenstein's use of montage is pioneering but its hard to love a film with no relatable characters or emotion. As an effective silent with a truly great central 'action' scene (the Odessa steps sequence) it works but I couldn't get invlolved - even at 76 minutes I was getting a little fidgetty.




Bill Clay -> (26/4/2011 3:26:27 PM)

I saw this a few years back accompanied by a full orchestra, quite impressive.




ARmy2510 -> (29/4/2011 12:52:27 PM)

For Christ sake, it was 1925! Not quite impressive?...




Whistler -> Battleship Potemkin (7/12/2011 4:06:27 PM)

I'd say films like Battleship Potemkin are important films, rather than particularly good ones - in my opinion, of course. I personally find it quite hard to engage with silent film. I feel a bit disconnected not be able to hear the characters talk, not hearing the emotion in someoneís voice. Even having no sound effects makes it harder for me to believe what I'm seeing. (Having said that, however, I do enjoy Nosferatu). I watched BP because it was an innovative film that explored various techniques that directors are still copying today, like which camera angles work and which don't, when a cut should occur to drive the plot forwards etc. The story itself I didnít find particularly engaging, and to be completely honest, I became a little bored. This doesnít mean I donít appreciate classic cinema, it just means that I donít want to pretend to think itís the greatest film ever made in order to sound Ďartisticí (and I'm also not accusing anybody who really does think this of pretending). Iím definitely NOT saying itís a bad film (I've given it 4 stars), and actually, for its time, itís really quite astonishing. But I do think, in regards to a comment I've seen of the film, that many films that have been made since are far superior, and given the choice to watch either this or The Godfather, I'd choose the latter every time. However, I appreciate that this effectively gave 'birth' to films like The Godfather, and that they may not have been as great without the likes of BP. I think it's important that people are aware of films like Battleship Potemkin and the influence they've had on modern cinema.




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.4.5 ANSI
0.0625